Re:Comparing Ember Octane and React
by pzuraq on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @10:53AM
(#23154630)
When hooks first came out and I started playing with the API, I had the same feeling! It felt refreshing, but I couldn't quite nail down why.
I don't think it's that you don't have to worry about lifecycles, in the end. You still do - you have to understand the lifecycles of your functions which are different than those of a component class, but they are lifecycles in there own way. What I think really makes hooks feel nice is you can _close over_ the small, self-contained lifecycles, and introduce them at any point in the program in a composable way. That's pretty neat actually, and what we've taken away from hooks currently.
Maybe that's not the only benefit they have, but it's a pretty large one, so I'm glad hooks decided to explore this new direction, even if I'm not completely sold on it (as in, wouldn't introduce it in Ember just yet).
I don't think it's that you don't have to worry about lifecycles, in the end. You still do - you have to understand the lifecycles of your functions which are different than those of a component class, but they are lifecycles in there own way. What I think really makes hooks feel nice is you can _close over_ the small, self-contained lifecycles, and introduce them at any point in the program in a composable way. That's pretty neat actually, and what we've taken away from hooks currently.
Maybe that's not the only benefit they have, but it's a pretty large one, so I'm glad hooks decided to explore this new direction, even if I'm not completely sold on it (as in, wouldn't introduce it in Ember just yet).