Re:Rails MVC VS Sproutcore MVC
by jerf on Friday March 11, 2011 @05:38PM
(#2315202)
In my opinion, there is no such thing as an MVC web application, if you are really serious about the term meaning something and not just being a pretty paint color to put on your framework. MVC has nowhere for a client/server to go, and that's the sort of detail that shouldn't be glossed over.
"Something like" MVC is certainly possible, but MVC directly is pretty much confined to something without a client/server in it, or a cloud, and also is pretty tightly coupled to Object Orientation, too.
I think it's better just to go with "separation of concerns" and "don't repeat yourself", and pretty much whatever comes out of the end of a design based on those things will be better than trying to jam MVC in a priori. Maybe it'll even be MVC, if that's what fits, but MVC isn't specially good, it's just one point of a myriad of points on the good-DRY/SoC frontier.
"Something like" MVC is certainly possible, but MVC directly is pretty much confined to something without a client/server in it, or a cloud, and also is pretty tightly coupled to Object Orientation, too.
I think it's better just to go with "separation of concerns" and "don't repeat yourself", and pretty much whatever comes out of the end of a design based on those things will be better than trying to jam MVC in a priori. Maybe it'll even be MVC, if that's what fits, but MVC isn't specially good, it's just one point of a myriad of points on the good-DRY/SoC frontier.