Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora
by davidmathers on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:42PM
(#2315035)
It devalued your contribution ... The way I look at it, your answer was helpful.
It's more useful to think in terms of signal to noise ratio rather than a binary helpful/unhelpful. It may have been helpful when considered in isolation but was it helpful enough to be valuable?
Raganwald nails it with: This type of answer is an Internet Cliché
When the ratio of advice and/or opinions and/or theories is 10:1 relative to actual answers to the question being asked (which is common) it's not enough to say those non-answers might be helpful. They have to meet a higher standard. Because they have a built in noise-cost they need to have a signal-value that is very very high.
A individually helpful answer can have a negative value when viewed in the context of the whole system.
So you think that raganwald's leaving is more valuable than allowing his highly-rated answer that a moderator didn't approve of to continue to display on the site?
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora
by davidmathers on Friday March 11, 2011 @05:13PM
(#2315125)
That's not why he left.
The way I look at it, your answer was helpful. Sure, it could have been more helpful to more people if it had been different; and there may well have been other better answers. Calling "not helpful" focuses on what it isn't, not what it is.