Re:Finding new physics will require a new particle collider
by horsawlarway on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:18PM
(#23137580)
I'd love it if we'd re-allocate some defense spending, but I find this argument pretty disingenuous.
The LHC cost about 4.75 billion during construction, and requires a yearly operating budget of around 1 billion dollars.
The total cost estimate for finding the Higgs was about 13.25 billion.
The B-2 bomber program cost 44 Billion (or an average cost of 2.1 billion per unit), but it resulted in considerably MORE jobs over a much longer time span, also led to several innovations in manufacturing/radar/ECS/Material science, and it costs LESS to maintain per year at ~850 million a year for all 21 units.
This all for a program that had immediate and obvious applicability (we got a physical object out the other side with clear purpose), and it was STILL the object of intense budgetary concerns.
Basically - It was a costs DISASTER and it was only 4 times the cost.
Not saying I'd rather have more bombers than another collider, but this is not the argument I would make...
The LHC cost about 4.75 billion during construction, and requires a yearly operating budget of around 1 billion dollars.
The total cost estimate for finding the Higgs was about 13.25 billion.
The B-2 bomber program cost 44 Billion (or an average cost of 2.1 billion per unit), but it resulted in considerably MORE jobs over a much longer time span, also led to several innovations in manufacturing/radar/ECS/Material science, and it costs LESS to maintain per year at ~850 million a year for all 21 units.
This all for a program that had immediate and obvious applicability (we got a physical object out the other side with clear purpose), and it was STILL the object of intense budgetary concerns.
Basically - It was a costs DISASTER and it was only 4 times the cost.
Not saying I'd rather have more bombers than another collider, but this is not the argument I would make...