Re:Getting Back to Work
by tsimionescu on Sunday May 10, 2020 @09:33AM
(#23132440)
Sweden's strategy is also unique in the world and failing badly at protecting some of their most vulnerable citizens. It's also based on unproven ideas, like immunity from Covid19 after you get it once.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I don't know that any ideas are "proven". Evidence based medicine works on just that:evidence. The hypothesis that you do not get immunity, given the evidence from all previously observed cases of coronaviruses is the least likely. Why would you then act as if it were true?
Re:Getting Back to Work
by concordDance on Sunday May 10, 2020 @11:08AM
(#23133194)
If immunity after getting it isn't viable, then surely a vaccine isn't either?
Stamping out COVID19 worldwide simply isn't practical, so isn't the omly option to just live with it? We manage to live with far worse things, like ageing.
Re:Getting Back to Work
by tsimionescu on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:59PM
(#23135620)
Aging is not killing hundreds of people in short succession in the same hospital. The only option to avoid much more significant disturbances in our daily life then we see now is to isolate for as long as possible, and then work tirelessly to perform contact tracing of the newly infected and catch outbreaks while they are small.
And I believe that a vaccine can succeed where natural immunity doesn't. For example, there are viruses where you only gain partial immunity from contacting the disease, but can end up with a worse form of the disease if exposed again, like with chicken pox (varicella) leaving the door open to shingles (zoster).