News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @03:56PM (#23118787)
Rights are not limited to "legal" rights.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @03:57PM (#23118805)
You're right, but the philosophical natural right is even more permissive.

The law is our way of tempering the natural right.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:03PM (#23118851)
In neither case, do you have the right to promote or otherwise further actions that will unnecessarily cause the death of innocents.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:36PM (#23119160)
Incorrect, on both counts. Especially the latter, because morality isn't absolute. What you think is a moral right can be different from what I think is a moral right.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:44PM (#23119248)
Under what moral framework do I have the right to cause the death of innocent people simply because I want a haircut? Or, because I'm a billionaire who wants to make more money? Do I have the right to kill you in self defense for suggesting so?
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:11PM (#23119512)
> Under what moral framework do I have the right to cause the death of innocent people simply because I want a haircut?

The same moral framework under which you have the right to contribute to killing 35,000 people/year because you want a quick/convenient way to get to work everyday.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:14PM (#23119551)
Except that I don't kill 35,000 people per year. Try again.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:27PM (#23119678)
Yes, and a COVID-negative individual doesn't kill, in your words, "60,000+ people" if they want to go about their lives during a pandemic.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:30PM (#23119709)
Well, in fact, I have contributed to killing 0 people in a car accident by driving. Can you reframe your objection now? If I spread the coronavirus by going about my day as normal, how many infections would that result in, and how many deaths, hmm?
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:33PM (#23119746)
Well, in fact, I have contributed to killing 0 people by getting a haircut during COVID! Can you maybe try a little harder to grasp the analogy?
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:37PM (#23119778)
There is no analogy to be had. When I get in my car, the overhwelming probability is that absolutely nobody will be killed by my action, including myself. If we resume "normal life," the overhwelming probabilty is that I will eventually contract the coronavirus, and there is a significant probability that I will be killed, or that my actions would kill someone else.

Do you not see the difference? Try a little harder to grasp reality.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:42PM (#23119826)
There absolutely is an analogy: in both cases, the risk you do as an individual in a vacuum is nearly 0. The aggregate risk of everyone engaging in that behavior is not only non-zero, but results in tens of thousands of deaths.

If we all started driving our cars again, the overwhelming probability is that someone will eventually get into a car accident and die, and in aggregate we've observed that to be about 35,000 every year.

If we all resumed a "normal life", the overwhelming probability is that 60,000+ people will die from COVID.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:51PM (#23119918)
> There absolutely is an analogy: in both cases, the risk you do as an individual in a vacuum is nearly 0.

This is absolutely untrue.

> In order to achieve herd immunity, scientists say that a community would need to have at least 60% of its population infected. That’s the lowest estimate I’ve been told. Other scientists have told me 80% to 90%. The reason this percentage isn’t precisely known is because it depends on things like exactly how contagious the virus is and also whether people who have been infected are immune forever, or if they lose immunity after a while, which researchers also are furiously working to figure out. [0]

With an infection fatality rate of 0.5% (which is on the conservative side), resuming normal activity means between 1.5 and 4.5% of the population will likely die. This is not an insignificant risk at all. In contrast, 35,000 dead from traffic accidents is .01% of the US population. This is precisely why your so called "analogy" is invalid. Why do you not realize this?

---

[0]: https://www.propublica.org/article/what-antibody-studies-can...

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:56PM (#23119969)
> With an infection fatality rate of 0.5% (which is on the conservative side), resuming normal activity means between 1.5 and 4.5% of the population will likely die. This is not an insignificant risk at all. In contrast, 35,000 dead from traffic accidents is .01% of the US population.

Right, so you are essentially making a tradeoff! You have decided that losing 0.01% of the US population is, to use your framing, an "insignificant risk". I don't disagree with that.

Your original argument was that we simply do not have the right to promote or otherwise further actions that will unnecessarily cause the death of innocents, even if there is an economic tradeoff to be had. I argued that we absolutely have the right to make tradeoffs with lives, we do it all the time. Sometimes the tradeoff is worth it, sometimes it isn't.

You have just argued to me that "the analogy is invalid" because in one case a lot of people die, and in the other case far fewer people die. You are essentially making the same tradeoff, under the same moral framework — only your boundary for what constitutes an acceptable number of deaths is different.

This is a difference in degree, and not kind.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:59PM (#23120011)
> Right, so you are essentially making a tradeoff! You have decided that losing 0.01% of the US population is, to use your framing, an "insignificant risk". I don't disagree with that.

I have not. I have stated that a moral framework that could theoretically justify driving cars does not also justify releasing lockdowns. I have made no normative statement about Americans driving cars. Please show me where I have, if you disagree.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:13PM (#23120138)
> I have stated that a moral framework that could theoretically justify driving cars does not also justify releasing lockdowns

It's the same moral framework, you're just coming out of it with a different decision based on the number of lives impacted.

> I have made no normative statement about Americans driving cars. Please show me where I have, if you disagree.

Your words:

"resuming normal activity means between 1.5 and 4.5% of the population will likely die. This is not an insignificant risk at all. In contrast, 35,000 dead from traffic accidents is .01% of the US population."

You've implicitly shown that there is a line you draw at the number of lives lost that you feel is unacceptable, and that's somewhere between 1.5-4.5% of the population. 0.01% of the population is acceptable to you (it is acceptable to me, too). Drawing this line is a normative point of view!

And my fundamental argument is that different people have different "lines". Your "line" isn't magically the universally correct one. We need to have the discussion to understand all of the "lines" we might be able to draw (ie what are the varying degrees of lockdown), what everyone's personal "lines" are, and then try and come up with the acceptable "line" for society.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:16PM (#23120161)
Where did I say 35,000 people dead was insignificant? The statement you quote literally does not say that. Again, I am claiming that even if you can justify .01% of the population dying in car accidents on the basis of "economic activity," then the same argument does not work for 150-450x as many deaths. You are putting words in my mouth when you say I claimed 35,000 deaths was acceptable.

Again, I note that although you say there are LOADS of frameworks that could justify this, you have not yet even articulated one. Why is that?

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:24PM (#23120216)
> Again, I am claiming that even if you can justify .01% of the population dying in car accidents on the basis of "economic activity," then the same argument does not work for 150-450x as many deaths.

And I'm arguing that '150-450x as many deaths' is an arbitrary limit. If you can justify 0.01% of the population dying in car accidents on the basis of "economic activity", can you justify 0.02%? 0.1%? 0.3%? 0.5%? 0.9%? 1%? 2%?

Where did it stop being justifiable by the same argument? My argument is that there is no objective line, it is strictly subjective. THAT is the moral framework.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:28PM (#23120249)
Your "slippery slope" justification literally does not work. I could use that same argument to say that anything that justifies one death justifies 90% of the population being killed. No sane individual believes that there's an argument for executing billions of people.

And, what if I believe even one death for the sake of economic activity is too many? What of your argument, then?

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by Gibbon1 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:46PM (#23120364)
Yeah the fallacy here is the fallacy of grey.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/dLJv2CoRCgeC2mPgj/the-fallac...

There is also an argument to be made that society spends a lot of resources[1] to keep automobile carnage low as it is. It would stand to reason that society response to something even dangerous would be proportionate.

[1] We have extensive and complicated vehicles laws. We have traffic cops performing surveillance 24/7. We ban dangerous drivers. We require cars have crash protection. We design roads to be as safe as possible. Goes on and on.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:00PM (#23120465)
Yes, and few people are arguing for a total reopening free-for-all.

The death projections from reopening account for the existing amount of COVID testing, people wearing face masks, self quarantining, and random sample tracing.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by Gibbon1 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:09PM (#23120896)
I think a fallacy of half measures are in play here. In that the shorter term needed for extreme measures will cost less in the long run. Consider this fall China, Vietnam, Australia, New Zealand will have been virus free for six months while the US and Sweden continues to fester.

The economic damage isn't proportional to the extremity of the measures, but of that multiplied by length of time they are imposed.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:38PM (#23120319)
First of all "capitalism" has nothing to do with this. Even a perfectly centrally planned socialist economy might come to the same conclusion. People need goods and services. Capitalism is one way to deliver them.

Second of all, I'm not really sure where you got "5,250,000+ deaths per year", because current projections with reopening of the economy is about 161,000 by Aug 4[1], and that's about 5 months since the outbreak, so let's call that 386,400 annualized. Let's say we get a vaccine in 2 years, for a total of about 772,800 deaths. That represents 0.2% of US population.

I want to make it clear that I, personally, do not think that it is acceptable for 0.2% of the US population to die, but I want to try and convey to you that it is entirely within the realm of possibility for REASONABLE people to conclude that 0.2% over a one-time 2-year interval is "okay", if they already think that 0.01% of Americans dying per year is already acceptable — because at that rate you reach the same 0.2% figure over 20 years, and it continues to grow unbounded.

> And, what if I believe even one death for the sake of economic activity is too many? What of your argument, then?

It's totally fair for you to have that opinion! But the vast majority of people do not believe that, and you absolutely cannot argue that people lack the moral right to believe that 1 death for the sake of the economy is acceptable.

[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/will-some-people-be-affect...

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:45PM (#23120355)
I did not mean to say that unnecessary deaths were the result of capitalism and only capitalism. I only used the "C" word to highlight that those interested in restarting the economy are those who will benefit the most from it. And, those people are not the vulnerable people on the ground making the sacrifices. Under socialism, the people who would benefit and the people making sacrifices would be identical, and that's the fundamental difference there. Sorry to have been unclear.

Regarding 5.25M deaths, I showed my work upthread on that. It's 1.5% of 328.2 million (approximate current US population). This is what the likely result would be if we just "resumed normal activity" and waited for herd immunity, which may or may not come.

> you absolutely cannot argue that people lack the moral right to believe that 1 death for the sake of the economy is acceptable.

Why not? No one has the moral authority to choose to end my life besides me.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:47PM (#23120373)
> Why not?

Because it is practically unenforceable, and almost nobody considers 1 death for "economic activity" to be unacceptable, so by extension means that everyone holds an immoral world view, and everyone is violating your supposed natural human law...in which case, of what use is that law?

If everyone is evil, then nobody is evil.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:58PM (#23120458)
Imperfection is not evil.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:08PM (#23120510)
Indeed, it is not.

To some people, opening the economy is “imperfect”, but acceptable.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:12PM (#23120543)
I don't consider it acceptable, but the number of people that would die if we literally just shut everything off (including "essential" services and utilities) is unacceptable. "The economy" as it exists today simply leaves too many people behind. When 8 billionaires have as much wealth as half the world, and when wealth is essentially freedom, that's what's unacceptable.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:19PM (#23120593)
Even that’s debatable, and its own ideological rabbit hole.

Today is my birthday and my wife is waiting for me, so I’ll have to tap out.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @09:29PM (#23121336)
Happy birthday!