Re:There is one, and only one strain of SARS-CoV-2
by kerkeslager on Friday May 08, 2020 @03:37PM
(#23118587)
> As a scientist, but not a technical expert in this field, I felt that this article read pretty straight forward. Though I will admit that there could be added clarity for a more general audience (pretty much all work can).
Yeah. My concern isn't that the meaning wasn't clear. My concern was that by focusing on the semantics of the jargon, it comes across as combative and alienates readers over something which is ultimately not important.
I think you and I are at a point of understanding where we're able to receive this feedback on the terminology and correct our own usage very quickly. I've certainly taken note.
Re:There is one, and only one strain of SARS-CoV-2
by godelski on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:03PM
(#23118848)
Then I mischaracterized your critique. I do think the author is combative. This is an unfortunately common problem in science discussions, but I think within the community is has become normalized to such a point that anyone that isn't a junior isn't really put off from it. I do think this is a thing the community can work on in general that would help bring people in (imo, everyone should be doing "science").
Re:There is one, and only one strain of SARS-CoV-2
by kerkeslager on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:05PM
(#23118871)
Well, more than one person hasn't understood my critique, which indicates that the problem may have been my communication. :)
Re:There is one, and only one strain of SARS-CoV-2
by godelski on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:12PM
(#23118925)
Well we're chimps that can barely communicate with one another even when we speak the same language. We'll always have room to improve. (considering that you're the top comment, I think more people accurately characterized your message. Comments are more likely to happen with a mischaracterization and can be selection bais)
> is the definition of the word "strain" really the important point you want to communicate?
I think in the author's case, yes. If you are unfamiliar with the subject you learn some nuance about the subject and the terminology used. A basic understanding of the science should have already clued you into that viruses don't replicate perfectly, so the reader should question at what point a change constitutes a new strain. The author answers this question in the beginning.
> A virus strain is an isolate with a different biological property, such as binding to a different receptor, or having a distinctly different stability at higher temperatures, to give just two of many possible examples.
So we learn simply that the different isolate has to have a new biological property. More akin to having a third arm rather than a difference in skin color.
The author circles back to this with a clear example:
> The most recent offender is a preprint claiming that SARS-CoV-2 with an amino acid change in the spike glycoprotein (D614G) increases the transmissibility of the virus.
> Until proven otherwise, their emergence is likely due to the founder effect. Let’s say a virus with D614G emerges during replication in a person’s respiratory tract. If viruses with that change infect the next person, and the next, and so on, then the D614G change will predominate. The change is simply __a single nucleotide polymorphism of little consequence.__
I do think here the author could have strengthened their argument by noting what the founder's effect is.
> (via wiki) the loss of genetic variation that occurs when a new population is established by a very small number of individuals from a larger population.
So the author gives a reasonable assertion for this observation. We then apply Occam's razor and we have the author's thesis. (He should have stated this explicitly)