The point is, the iPad's real competitors don't beat it in any of those categories except for camera. (Also, Gruber said in his own review that he got identical battery life to the previous model.) The Xoom is the only tablet that promises 4G and Flash and got mediocre reviews even without those components, which will probably make it run worse.
Re:Bending Over Backwards
by greatDismay on Thursday March 10, 2011 @08:53PM
(#2311783)
I have a Xoom and I don't know why people are giving it such a bad rap. It does everything I want it to do and it does it really fast.
Re:Bending Over Backwards
by Kylekramer on Thursday March 10, 2011 @08:55PM
(#2311788)
So? A book still can have flaws if all the other books in the genre are worse.
Also, I am pretty sure Mossberg didn't lie about the battery. Mileage varies. Does he have to check with everyone else to make sure his numbers check out?
Re:Bending Over Backwards
by ZeroGravitas on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:27AM
(#2312790)
What do you mean by "real" competitors? The Galaxy Tab has had Flash since launch and is mentioned by name in the article.
But they really should just rename it to the No True Competitors to the iPad Fallacy:
Re:Bending Over Backwards
by ghostofgruber on Thursday March 10, 2011 @08:52PM
(#2311775)
^^^ Here comes the HN anti-Gruber mob. Grab the pitchforks!
Hilarious, but true. (I've noticed a very strong, anti-Gruber sentiment developing on HN over the past couple months.)
I wish more people would just admit to not liking Gruber.
Re:Bending Over Backwards
by Dylanlacey on Thursday March 10, 2011 @09:17PM
(#2311851)
I dislike Gruber. I dislike him because I don't think his content is worthwhile. I dislike him because I find his content INCREDIBLY biased. I dislike him because he applies fanboyism and tries to pass it off as objective criticism.
And to be perfectly honest, I dislike him MORE because of how many people are huge fans of his. I don't find him notable or worthwhile and so the excess exposure just heightens my distaste. It's not logical, but it's true.
...and tries to pass it off as objective criticism.
There's a lot of biased individuals on the internet who post in rational drag every day. What's amazing about Gruber is how he wears his biases on his sleeve and people still claim he's trying to hide them.
I think Gruber frequently presents biased statements or opinions as facts (e.g. his rant about fonts on Android devices being unreadable was just strange) but if you take his name off this piece and read it objectively then he's actually making reasonable arguments against Mossberg's article. I don't mind this piece as much as some of his other stuff.
The funny thing is Mossberg's review is overwhelmingly positive.