The last tweet reads:
For what it’s worth, nytimes senior editor mark bulik said, “we’ve learned a number of lessons from months of testing... clear, powerful words and a conversational tone make a big difference.”
"Guess what government figure just hit 14.7% today?"
"These 3 sectors hate the latest unemployment figures!"
Haha, 'clear, powerful words...'. That's an understatement.
This Bill Maher clip seems somewhat relevant:
So do we want to be correct, or do we want to win?
I know I've often fallen prey to this effect. You feel like your team has a disadvantage and then think the other team crazy when they claim the same. Almost like our brains are trying desperately to let us feel justified in relaxing our moral code.
Of course, confirmation biases and other related phenomena help us construct and reinforce these perspectives.
judge Claude Frollo longed to purge the world of vice and sin / and he saw corruption everywhere, except within.
Obviously this applies more to comments than to submissions but the comments are a large part of the user experience here so whether HN is "based on this premise of winning" boils down to a question of the importance of the comment section.
I want to win, but I want to make sure that the thesis has some modeling diligence =)
It's nice if you can do both. Unfortunately, most systems in the world are actively being gamed which means adding additional constraints to systems (like being correct, clear, forthcoming, honest, etc.) often put you at a disadvantage.
I’d much rather be correct, and let people make their own decisions. Otherwise this thing you call “freedom” is just empty words on a bit of paper.
No, not control - principal reduction of problems associated with climate crisis.
Just a theory but titles of threads do matter. I'm not claiming it's the reason in your case but it might be.
- Your previous title with no activity: "BLS Reports 14.7% Unemployment Rate"
- This title that attracted upvotes: "April Unemployment Rate Rose to a Record 14.7%"
Your title's matter-of-fact tone is clinical and missing the impact of the 14.7%? Hmmm... the 14.7%... so... is that a lot or a little?
The phrase "rose to a record" is immediate spoonfeeding of the impact to potential readers.
Good newspapers like WSJ, NYT, Buzzfeed, etc know how to craft titles to get readers to click on them. This is often abused and thus disparaged as SEO/clickbait. In this case, providing a little bit of a statistic's impact could be helpful.