Does https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-react-sdk/pull/4531 look any better? O:-)
> The one thing I'm waiting for is rooms where participants are hidden, so that you actually get closer to a pubsub system.
This is surprisingly hard (if you don't know what users are in a room, how do you know what servers to send messages to?) but we can provide at least a cosmetic solution (have the server filter out members below a given power level when relaying to the client). https://github.com/vector-im/riot-web/issues/6417 is the bug to upvote :)
Hey that's actually kinda sexy ! I'm not looking specifically for IRC-style <timestamp/nick/message>, I do like it when it takes a bit more space for the user, but I find this rendering nice to the eyes.
In the quote though, why is the user cast away on the right ? Would be more consistent to put it right next to the timestamp of the quoted text
Also, the nick is chopped at the end without any indicator that it is (like a [...] at the end or something)
All nitpicking, I know, I'll try this as soon as it lands because I already like it :)
> https://github.com/vector-im/riot-web/issues/6417 is the bug to upvote :)
I'm following it closely ! I can't wait to experiment around that, Matrix.org can be and needs to be much more than just a messaging protocol, there's everything needed to get rid of centralized silos of (micro-)blogging, status- or photo-based social networks, ...
BTW thank you for doing this and thank you for leading it all the way to it is today and to where it's gonna be tomorrow, there's a reason protocols fail or succeed and it's often not in the technical intricacies but definitely in the leadership that spearheads its spread. Matrix seems to be the one that has the biggest momentum for now :)
> Also, the nick is chopped at the end without any indicator that it is (like a [...] at the end or something)
These were just bugs in the first cut. I'll spin up a dev client and grab a screenshot of the final version (i think dev finished on it today!)
> BTW thank you for doing this
np. I just hope we realise the full potential of the project :) For what it's worth, I hope that Matrix can be to Slack/Discord what Linux was to Solaris/AIX. So, we just need to not screw up...
Substantially better than the default Riot layout. I hope this gets merged and I get to switch to this soon.
That said, I'd still like a more compact version of the same that further reduces the spacing/padding to make more information fit on a single screen.
> This is surprisingly hard (if you don't know what users are in a room, how do you know what servers to send messages to?)
Can you expand on what your threat model is in this case? Because I assumed rakoo was just talking about a cosmetic change (possibly coupled with allowing pseudonymous users with low (read-only) permission levels, but you'd have to go out of your way to break that).
Personally though I can't stand the conversation view in Riot, the spacing between the nickname, the avatar and the text feels just wrong and I can't see in a glance who is talking and says what (yes, even with the compact view). It's minor, but it's the one I have under my eyes at all times so it's there. For now I'm using another snappier client (https://neo.pixie.town/) because of this issue.
Apart from this client-specific issue that doesn't say anything about the protocol itself, everything is fine.
The one thing I'm waiting for is rooms where participants are hidden, so that you actually get closer to a pubsub system. I have some ideas I want to try and play with, but this is needed if you want to keep some privacy