Why is Apache continuing to fork new workers ad infinitum? That’s a denial of service attack waiting to happen, and the answer surely isn’t “oh let’s just automate the rebooting”...
Edit: you’ve edited your comment to say it’s a DoS as well, so looks like we’re on the same page here, the software is garbage.
I try to be slow to jump to that conclusion ... so often there are reasons for things to be the way they are. The software tools and the hardware capabilities were very, very different in the aughties, and many people currently writing software don't really seem to appreciate by just how much. It may be the case that things could have been done differently, perhaps better, but then again, once you know the full story, maybe not.
Some time ago I wrote up a war story from the mid-nineties and had some current software people crap all over it. When I started to explain about the machine limitations of the time the bluster increased, and among the replies I got was "The software was crap".
Ever since then I've been interested in the contexts for these stories. So often I hear "Well you shouldn't have done it like that!" rather than an enquiring:
"OK, let's assume some clever people wrote this, I wonder what the pressures were that made them come out with that solution."
I've learned a lot by approaching things that way, instead of simply declaring: The software was garbage.
Pressure from everyone to get something shipped and out-the-door - never-mind the technical debt - and after it ships management is only interested in further growth fuelled by more features - deepening the technical debt.
As for the problem of Apache keeling over too easily - that’s because Apache (at the time - and I think still now) is based on “one thread per HTTP request” - or one thread per connection. Asynchronous (or rather: coroutine-based) request handling was very esoteric in the late-1990s and early-2000s - and required fundamentally different program architecture - no-one was going to rewrite their CGI programs to do that - and Perl script based applications couldn’t do anything at all. Asynchronous HTTP request handling only really became mainstream when NodeJS started getting popular about 7-8 years ago - but, to my knowledge, besides ASP.NET Core - no other web application platform treats asynchronous request handling as a first-class feature.
Nginx first came out in 2002. It was being used widely by something like 2008.
> no other web application platform treats asynchronous request handling as a first-class feature
Huh? Web application platforms that do this have been around since the late 1990s. (Heck, there was one written in Python in the late 1990s, it was called "Medusa".) They just weren't "popular" back then.
Nginx, OTOH, was popular before NodeJS even existed, let alone before NodeJS became mainstream.
Nginx does the async stuff properly I believe but there's still the nonsense of forking child processes.
Besides that, Python, Java and PHP have had mature async web stacks available for years as well. Is there any commonly used language that doesn’t?
Ed: or maybe a blog post to be repeatedly deployed in threads like this one.
Thank you.
Cheers.
Yeah, I agree in many cases that's the issue, as the author pointed out in the last paragraph.
Let me also add that on this particular stack this happens with caching enabled (W3 Total Cache). Without cache it struggles with 10 concurrent clients (TTFB > 5 seconds). 100 MB per client to serve what's pretty much a grid of products and a button, it's scary
WordPress itself is not garbage (at least not for those reasons), but WordPress + a bunch of plugins hammered together is a different beast.
The problem is you have to manually tune the number of max workers a bit based on estimated resource usage.
For example, maybe in the average second you see 1 login request (CPU-bound password hashing), 10 page views (database connection bound), 100 image views (IO/client speed bound), and 0.01 login sessions being bounced between servers (???? bound). And your server is limited to 111 connections per second.
But when the site goes down? Users can't load images until they've seen pages, and can't see pages until they've logged in, so now you're processing 111 login attempts per second when your tuning assumed a fraction of that.
This was pretty much not easily possible (with suphp, mod_php) until FPM which has a per site worker pool.
Solved a lot of problems for us as a shared hosting provider.
Restarting was a bear. We had to "warm up" the application server by hitting some of the web pages so caches would get populated etc., before opening the system to public traffic (which, as I recall, we controlled with IP address aliases) or else it would die again.
Finally we put the system behind an F5 load balancer which resulted in a much more even distribution of traffic -- that, coupled with the "warm up" crawl, let to a greatly stabilized system and highest ever (and growing) page views.
Yup, it's pretty much a DDoS. It's simple to test. Spin up Wordpress + Woocommerce (a common ecommerce stack) in a Digitalocean 1 GB droplet.
Now ab -n 1000 -c 30 the home page, that's 30 concurrent clients
Watch MySQL die, Apache get killed because out of memory, and...
root@wootest01:~# reboot
-bash: fork: Cannot allocate memory