This is a really good take on it for those who aren't into reading scientific papers. It's totally plausible HCQ does help a bit. If true, it changes virtually nothing about our current situation. The decision making is all the same.
Honest question: why?
(Note: my background includes pharmacology, so I am more interested in pharmacological options rather than vaccines)
Yes, everyone who has their life saved by this treatment is happy, and it's worth chasing small improvements on the margin... but...
(It's worth noting that the (very) little evidence from controlled trials that we have leans more in the direction of harm than benefit, too. But the same argument holds for e.g. remdesivir where we do have some decent evidence).
Unsure about fatality (the data is a statistically insignificant trend), but the NIAID trial preliminary data points that remedesivir does cut recovery time by 30% (11 days vs 14 days) according to their interim report. I have to dig up the exact definition.
Yes, not HCQ, but data on drugs exist. Too bad it's probably one of the hardest to manufacture.
Even cutting recovery time by 22% doesn't lower peak ICU usage very much-- less than 22% because there's still the effect of the exponential peak.
The point is it doesn't affect policy / the fundamentals of the situation in any way. It's something that individual patients are happy and thankful for, but the overall societal situation is the same. A treatment that reduced the chance of ending up in ICU by 50% would, but this isn't enough to move the needle.
I beg to differ. At least on paper, there is at least one trial (target size 3000 individuals, but they claim they might have enough power with lower numbers):
I am placing the odds of a positive result at around 25%. For vitamin D supplements to people who are deficient, I place the odds at 50%. Not that anyone cares what I think the odds are.
Yet we have to argue about the ?!@#!$ thing repeatedly, because public figures (we all know who) decided to push this idea irresponsibly as a miracle cure. So now all the people on one side of the discussion have to crow about every positive result as if it vindicates the original rhetoric.
It does not. I mean, this might work a little! It might save some lives at the margin. It's not going to significantly affect the course of the pandemic. It's just not.