Re:Future of the human climate niche
by xpe on Tuesday May 05, 2020 @02:04AM
(#23076982)
First, your phrasing is vague; please be more specific.
If your comment is intended as a general dismissal of climate predictions, my replies would be:
* What would you recommend instead?
* Would you recommend that no one make model-based predictions at all?
* Would you recommend that model-based predictions be dismissed entirely?
All models are wrong, but some are useful. [1] In other words, models are all simplifications in different kinds of ways, but a critical, skeptical mind can find value in them.
Science is largely based on models. Some may think current scientific theories are the complete truth, but history has shown this is not a reliable prediction. Still, you work with the best models you have, since the alternative is worse. Still, the only way forward we know is starting from where we are.
If your comment is intended as a general dismissal of climate predictions, my replies would be:
* What would you recommend instead?
* Would you recommend that no one make model-based predictions at all?
* Would you recommend that model-based predictions be dismissed entirely?
All models are wrong, but some are useful. [1] In other words, models are all simplifications in different kinds of ways, but a critical, skeptical mind can find value in them.
Science is largely based on models. Some may think current scientific theories are the complete truth, but history has shown this is not a reliable prediction. Still, you work with the best models you have, since the alternative is worse. Still, the only way forward we know is starting from where we are.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_models_are_wrong