News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why can't I send faxes from my phone? by kelnos on Monday May 04, 2020 @05:08AM (#23065897)
Wish this wasn't the highest-rated comment, as it's not correct.

If it needed a "56kHz channel", it would not have worked in the phone-over-copper-wire days either.

If we assume the parent meant 56kbps, that's still incorrect. The fastest fax machines use V.34bis modems (ignoring ISDN), which give you 33.6kbps, though many (most?) still support the oldest standard, V.27, at 2400bps!

The real issue sending a (T.30) fax over a cell phone line would be jitter and packet loss, since most cell networks are IP-based nowadays. T.30 is not very resilient to noise or timing issues. There's the T.38 standard, which was designed for sending faxes over a packet-switched network, but it's still sensitive to timing issues (esp. since often you'd be talking to a real fax machine on the other end, after going through a T.38/T.30 gateway).

Cell phones certainly don't give you the bandwidth that a copper landline does, but it'd certainly be enough to transmit a fax... if you could keep the error rate low enough... which I doubt.

(Source: I built the initial production version of Twilio's fax product.)

Re:Ask HN: Why can't I send faxes from my phone? by 2rsf on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:03AM (#23067497)
You are confusing bitrates here, the fax emits an analog signal and doesn't interface the digital line directly- it's not a digital packet switch protocol.

Those 2400bps are not using 2400bps from the line, but are modulated to an analog signal that uses the lines full bitrate. From Nyquist–Shannon sampling theorem we know that a 56bps line can transfer something like half of it in analog form, so 33.6 is marginal.

T.38 is sensitive since it needs to end the analog side, practically receiving the fax.

Fax in general is sensitive since the standards have left too much freedom for implementers, especially like you said in the timing parts, causing incompatibilities between machines.

(Source: I have built fax relay over VoIP products in the late 90's)