This (and much of the article) is incorrect. Debian went through an extensive evaluation process at the time, over the course of 4 months, considering several different init systems, and chose systemd based on this detailed technical evaluation. That evaluation also considered sysvinit, openrc, and upstart. All of that evaluation occurred publicly, and is archived on Debian's mailing lists and bug-tracking system.
As a programmer in embedded, Systemd feels like it solves problems we didn't have, and introduces problems we didn't have. I what point is it more conservatism than "if it ain't broken, don't fix it"? God only knows.
Well, every time the Systemd topic pops on HN or Reddit (and even other places where you wouldn't expect it [1]), I go fetch some popcorn... It seems that different people have different needs and different experiences, hence the flamewars.
See https://lwn.net/Articles/808217/ for the outcome of the GR.
I might be misinterpreting the result, but "Systemd but we support exploring alternatives" means, to me, that there is some unhappiness here. To begin with, I believe the GR would not have happened if there was no issue to be discussed?
I realize that you have been one of the more visible members of the pro-systemd side for years now, so I'd definitely like a more coherent rebuttal to both the historical and technical sections.
Of course, you'd probably consider any kind of response to be undignified, and I understand.
As for the rest, I consider https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23062725 a good start. systemd was successful because it provided working code that people (including distribution maintainers) wanted to use, for a variety of reasons. This is the type of problem where no amount of architecture-in-a-vacuum discussions make up for actually doing the work and handling all the myriad cases that come up when people use it in practice. systemd did that; the next init system after systemd will need to do that as well.
Debian did _not_ choose to use Systemd. Debian was forced to choose between adopting Systemd despite going against the very principals of Debian, or loosing Gnome. They were put it a very difficult position.
Ubuntu did _not_ choose to use Systemd. Ubuntu, using Debian upstream, decided not to break from Debian. Shuttleworth, the founder of Ubuntu, has a very sublime message about it at the time.
I'm personally of the opinion that when forced into a corner, do not side with whoever pushed you into that corner. The Debian technical committee did not have that resolve, they took the easy way out. Lots of Debian-derived distros followed suit out of necessity.
My understanding (I believe detailed in the article) is that Debian, at least, chose systemd because they were forced to if they wanted a reasonable default GNOME experience for their users. If they hadn't, GNOME would have been missing some features that would have been obvious and jarring.
You can certainly argue that they made the wrong call there, and that they should have pushed back (though arguably by the time Debian got there, that ship had already sailed), but "chose systemd voluntarily" is an incorrect simplification.