What's more, the 3-digit "security" code (pardon me, whilst I scoff) for these cards is printed on the card! If you hand someone your card, you're already saying that you trust them not to keep your card number and security code and submit false charges. The Square reader isn't making that process any harder or easier; it's totally irrelevant.
The law may have put it on the issuer, but the issuers just fob it off on the merchants.
> The truth is credit card "security" is a bad joke.
Word.
[EDIT:] Some additional thoughts: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2305899l
The fundamental problem is that the credit card system works by requiring the customer to provide the merchant with all of the credentials necessary to make a transaction. We could have inexpensive devices that receive payment details, display them on cheap LCDs, and digitally sign them if the user confirms. Such a device would be about as complex as a pocket calculator, and as secure as any application of digital signatures. Nobody is moving on them because of the chicken/egg problem.
I've read that people will attach skimmers to gas station pumps/etc to get card info, so I assume there's more to be skimmed than just credit card numbers. So if you have 1 waiter with a Square-skimmer (or any other kind) and another without, can the first one get any more fraud-ready data than the second?
As usual, Le Wik to the rescue: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_stripe_card#Financial_...
Looks like a skimmer will get you account number, name, expiration date, and some verification numbers.
> So if you have 1 waiter with a Square-skimmer (or any other kind) and another without, can the first one get any more fraud-ready data than the second?
No, if you give your card to a malicious waiter he can skim all of its data. Because you gave it to him.
in practice it will boil down to how much VISA/MC like Square. i cannot imagine they see this expansion of CC billing to a new kind of merchants as a bad thing.
The truth is credit card "security" is a bad joke. The only real defense these days is the fact that every payment processor has extremely sensitive fraudulent transaction detection systems because of the consumer protection laws that put fraud liability on the card issuer instead of the consumer. The whole system is a relic from the days before the internet and the only way to fix it is to replace it with something better like NFC.