News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by shrimp_emoji on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:50PM (#23053975)
Imagine that having the mask encourages you to go out and be around people.

If you would otherwise self-isolate if you didn't have a mask, the mask has increased your chances of getting yourself and others sick.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by kinkrtyavimoodh on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:52PM (#23053993)
This is because the advice was delivered in a hare-brained manner and a month late.

It should always have been a combination of mask wearing from day 1 and stopping any large gatherings. Combine that with social distancing and you get most of the benefits. Now we have already infected so many people and are trying to close the barn door when the horse has long fled.

Before the lockdowns people were going about their merry lives WITHOUT masks. If they were doing exactly the same things but WITH masks, we would still be better off.

A coordinated advice in this case is important. Without a central authority advising for masks, people who do choose to wear them look like loony conspiracy theorists, but if there is central guidance for doing it, it quickly changes public perception.

The mask advice should have come in February, followed by bans on large gatherings (25+ people or some number), and then the lock downs could have come in a limited fashion in March as needed.

All those cute videos of cutting TShirts and socks and what nots to make masks could have been shown in Feb and people would have used them. Instead the authorities chose to tell such a stupid lie that it's almost insulting to our intelligence.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by loopz on Saturday May 02, 2020 @04:06PM (#23054505)
Citation for such lies?
Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by cameldrv on Saturday May 02, 2020 @11:09PM (#23056602)
Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by loopz on Sunday May 03, 2020 @06:03AM (#23058048)
More specifically this tweet then on 29th of February 2020:

  https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/1233725785283932160

  U.S. Surgeon General
  @Surgeon_General
  29th Feb.
  Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS!

  They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus, 
  but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk! 
  http://bit.ly/37Ay6Cm
But wasn't this appropriate for that situation and time? If there were oversupply, sure, and enough time to train the public, and maybe some evidence that masks are not detrimental to contagion for untrained people. There's also a huge difference between a highly contagious situation, and one after physical distancing have halted the spread. You would want the real masks used where appropriate.

What is surely to happen after this debacle though, is that many official recommendations and plans will have to account for pandemic outbreaks and remedy many of the shortcomings of current funding cuts.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by gridlockd on Sunday May 03, 2020 @12:52PM (#23060181)
> "They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus"

This is true. Masks don't protect you from catching COVID-19.

Masks may lower (but not eliminate) spread of virus particles. We don't have any evidence that this reduces infection rate, but it's plausible, at least for droplets.

If the virus spreads mostly by aerosol however, then mandated masks are probably counterproductive, because if the government says "wear masks" the people will hear "wear masks and you'll be fine", because that is what they want to hear.

All you smart rational types out there might not think like that, but I have heard this reasoning first hand from ordinary people. It's a real problem.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by cameldrv on Sunday May 03, 2020 @11:56PM (#23064411)
Masks protect both directions. Some masks protect better than others. If masks don't protect you from getting COVID, why do healthcare workers wear them, and why should we reserve for them a product that doesn't work?

I understand wanting there to be enough for HCWs. If so, say that without the lie. If there aren't enough for HCWs, restrict purchase by the general public and say that they will be available to the general public when there are adequate supplies.

When the health authorities lie to the public, they lose credibility, and they need that credibility if they're going to ask people to do extreme things like not leave their houses for an extended period of time.

It's really just like a condom. They work, some better than others, but none are perfect. The general public can understand that.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by gridlockd on Monday May 04, 2020 @03:40AM (#23065469)
> Masks protect both directions.

Cite me some evidence that shows that simple (non-FFP) masks or surgical masks protect the wearer against any virus. To the best of my knowledge, There isn't any such evidence and it's not scientifically plausible that they would protect.

> If masks don't protect you from getting COVID, why do healthcare workers wear them, and why should we reserve for them a product that doesn't work?

Because healthcare workers do get infected (a lot) and you don't want them to spread the virus (or other pathogens) around either.

We also need to differentiate between FFP masks which may offer some protection against viruses and surgical masks, which do not. It is mainly the FFP masks that are in short supply.

> When the health authorities lie to the public, they lose credibility, and they need that credibility if they're going to ask people to do extreme things like not leave their houses for an extended period of time.

Maybe, but that statement I quoted is strictly not a lie.

> It's really just like a condom.

No, it isn't, not even close. It's like avoiding pregnancy by wrapping your dick in a piece of linen. It just doesn't work. There's no evidence that it works. It's not plausible that it would work.

> The general public can understand that.

You, presumably intelligent and well-educated, don't even understand it. You still believe the mask protects the wearer when it does not. I have no hopes the general public will understand it.

To be clear, I'm not against wearing masks because I hope that it can reduce droplet infections and it's a net benefit. That's just my hope though, not my firmly-held belief.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by cameldrv on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:40AM (#23069326)
Sure, here's a Cochrane review that shows the opposite of what you say. Have you looked at the scientific literature on this? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2190272/pdf/bmj...

Even a surgical mask provides protection to the wearer. A professional-grade surgical mask provides N95 level filtration, it just doesn't seal to the face like an N95. That means that some of the air coming in will not be filtered. However, much of it is, and larger, non aerosolized ballistic droplets will be stopped and absorbed by a mask.

Re:Data do not back cloth masks to limit Covid-19, experts say by gridlockd on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:36PM (#23071620)
> Sure, here's a Cochrane review that shows the opposite of what you say.

It doesn't.

> Have you looked at the scientific literature on this?

Yes, I have, including this particular review as well as several of the reviewed papers.

I have yet to find a single convincing study that shows that simple masks protect the wearer against viruses. If it existed, people would be waving it around and governments would have no reason to not ask people to wear them. Simple masks were never in short supply.

This review makes abundantly clear that virtually all the studies are of poor quality. Note that the effect found in this review is not that large (+13% over washing hands) whereas the effect of wearing a gown is much larger (+27% over washing hands). Yet I haven't seen any big discussion on what kind of gowns people should be wearing out in public.