Re:A Proposal to Admit New States for the Purpose of Amendin...
by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 01, 2020 @11:43PM
(#23048955)
"Let's game the system so that we can change the rules to be what we think they should be!"
Does anybody see a problem with this? Not necessarily with the desired changes (though I think they are highly dangerous), but with the methodology? We're deep into "ends justify the means" here.
"We deserve to have things go the way we think they should! They didn't, so the rules must be unfair!" (Never mind that it's the rules that we've played by for 200 years, and that their side has won as often as they lost under those rules.) "So we should change the rules so that we always win, because we deserve to!" That's the cry of entitled losers everywhere. But do we really want the rules to be drawn up by whining, entitled losers? That's not a way to get good rules.
And, you're going to create new states out of DC's 127 neighborhoods? 127 new states? And your goal is also that "all citizens are represented by equal-sized (House) districts"? Well, the population of DC is 702,000. Divided into 127 districts, that gives 5,500 people per district. (Unless you want to have one House district represent more than one State, which seems to me to be problematic.) 330,000,000 people in the United States would give you a House of 60,000 members. That's probably not workable.
This whole thing smacks of "one person, one vote, one time". If they win (not necessarily the Democrats, but people that back this crackpot idea), they'll stack the deck so thoroughly that they'll never lose again. Such people do not deserve your vote; rather they deserve being opposed as strongly as possible.
And what in the world has happened to Harvard Law, that they're supporting garbage like this?
Does anybody see a problem with this? Not necessarily with the desired changes (though I think they are highly dangerous), but with the methodology? We're deep into "ends justify the means" here.
"We deserve to have things go the way we think they should! They didn't, so the rules must be unfair!" (Never mind that it's the rules that we've played by for 200 years, and that their side has won as often as they lost under those rules.) "So we should change the rules so that we always win, because we deserve to!" That's the cry of entitled losers everywhere. But do we really want the rules to be drawn up by whining, entitled losers? That's not a way to get good rules.
And, you're going to create new states out of DC's 127 neighborhoods? 127 new states? And your goal is also that "all citizens are represented by equal-sized (House) districts"? Well, the population of DC is 702,000. Divided into 127 districts, that gives 5,500 people per district. (Unless you want to have one House district represent more than one State, which seems to me to be problematic.) 330,000,000 people in the United States would give you a House of 60,000 members. That's probably not workable.
This whole thing smacks of "one person, one vote, one time". If they win (not necessarily the Democrats, but people that back this crackpot idea), they'll stack the deck so thoroughly that they'll never lose again. Such people do not deserve your vote; rather they deserve being opposed as strongly as possible.
And what in the world has happened to Harvard Law, that they're supporting garbage like this?