News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by stiray on Friday May 01, 2020 @06:41AM (#23040775)
How I am handling it (required mail server):

Each email adhering to some rule (magicmarker[a-f0-9]+)goes to my account.

Each registration anywhere gets unique email address generated as magicmarker<b64(hash(domain+salt))>@mydomain.com Salt is there to keep it unguessable.

When I get any spam, I can redirect it to /dev/null and verify from where it came from to sent hate mail to domain owner or whatever.

0 spam. 0 tracability. Ability to track who sold/leaked my mail address.

Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by the_jeremy on Friday May 01, 2020 @11:34AM (#23043062)
If others reading this don't want to run their own mail server, other services offer the ability to generate suffixes (a la `+SignupPageFoo`) via other characters.

The one I use (purelymail.com) allows for underscores to serve this purpose, which will never be stripped. It's also super cheap (less than $1/month), though because of its low volume and AWS IP, my messages have a problem with getting marked as spam. The next comparable service I found that offered effectively infinite addresses was $50/year, so I fall back to gmail if I really need to send email.

Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by stiray on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:13PM (#23053708)
This is not adequate. The + character is very well known part of standard and it is very simple to remove it, one search and replace would do on whole email list.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by the_jeremy on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:35PM (#23071614)
The + character is only "part of standard" for gmail and whoever else chooses to copy them. This is why I mentioned that the provider I'm using allows _ to be used the same as +, which will not be stripped or replaced by anyone ingesting email addresses.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by propogandist on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:37PM (#23048642)
Fastmail supports email domain wildcards / catch-all rules whereas providers like Outlook do not.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by dhimes on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:12AM (#23040926)
I thought the bad guys knew to strip the markers by now.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by zenexer on Friday May 01, 2020 @08:50AM (#23041461)
That + symbol is part of a pseudo-regex; it’s not part of the email address. You’re probably thinking of the email+whatever@whatever syntax, which isn’t what’s being described here. There’s nothing to strip in this case.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by dhimes on Friday May 01, 2020 @01:23PM (#23044364)
Whoops- you are correct. Pre-coffee me mis-read that. Thanks for the heads-up.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by swiley on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:28AM (#23041001)
According to the RFC ‘+’ is a valid character and tagged addresses (which aren’t mentioned) represent unique users (so removing the marker could result in the email not being delivered at all.)

IME: I’ve never had anyone remove it (although some don’t accept it and others will have bugs that result in an unusable account if you register with it.) I used one with the company I most recently interviewed at (they used a third party service for the HR site and I’ve had trouble with sites like that selling my email address which is just so enraging honestly.) Every. Single. Time. I logged in to fill out a form after getting hired I had to call HR and have them reset my account because of some weird bug.

Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by petercooper on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:39AM (#23042406)
According to the RFC ‘+’ is a valid character and tagged addresses (which aren’t mentioned) represent unique users (so removing the marker could result in the email not being delivered at all.)

Though similarly, email usernames ('local part') are case sensitive but I've never encountered a mail server where this was the case. I imagine if a nefarious party stripped the markers, they'd lose the tiniest percentage of their audience that way.

(Aside: Your own approach to using + is quite clever as it's the total opposite to most users, so you'll see who pulls this trick ;-))

Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by steerablesafe on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:21AM (#23040973)
The trick is to forward emails with no marker to spam. Sure they can strip markers but I assume they don't replace markers to match my "canonical" email address.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by stiray on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:21AM (#23040975)
You will have to elaborate, I don't understand. Marker is here just to handle mail on server side and I can easly upgrade it to hash of hash + salt and handle it programatically on server but there was never any need for it. And anyway I couldn't care less, without it mail is invalid, still 0 spam. And I am doing it for last 10 years so it is battle proven.
Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by sealjam on Friday May 01, 2020 @08:43AM (#23041418)
I think the responder misread your message and assumed you were adding a suffix like \+\w+ to the end of your email addresses like [email protected] -> [email protected]

Several email providers treat a + symbol as the end of the first part of the address and ignore everything between it and the @.

I think the responder’s point was that analytics providers just ignore things after a + too

Re:Millions of email addresses leaking to advertising and an... by dhimes on Friday May 01, 2020 @01:24PM (#23044372)
Yes, that's exactly what happened. Oops.