News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:23PM (#23036311)
I did not read the article in detail, but a keyword search and quick skim did not show anything about base load or peak load. I don't think you can really talk seriously about energy policy without mentioning those.

Solar doesn't produce energy at night, Wind doesn't produce energy when the wind doesn't blow.

---

My personal opinion is that the grid will have to get a lot smarter to realize the benefits of cheap solar, and that home power distribution and appliances will have to get smarter.

Re:Zombie Coal by jcrawfordor on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:41PM (#23036489)
The point the article makes is that coal is still a poor choice, all this aside. natural gas has the same reliability properties at a lower cost.
Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:16PM (#23037816)
Natural gas is not universally available and cheap. It is also tied to politics in Europe as much of their natural gas is from Russia.

---

To be clear, I'm not in love with coal; I'd much rather have a mostly solar powered grid, but I think it will be more expensive and complicated to get there than just "put some solar on it"

When solar wins some percent of the total market (20%?, 40%?; I don't know) then things get complicated. Immediately obvious is the fact that generation is tied to sunlight, so when it is dark out due to rain or nighttime or shortened seasons, grid capacity will be reduced.

There are other issues besides production though. Generators with great big spinning metal shafts currently (heh) control the frequency of alternating current power that we use in our homes. Direct Current Inverters can mimic the A/C sine wave, but it's not exactly the same.

It's great to have batteries or other storage, but will you have storage equivalent to 20 or 40% of grid capacity? Or will you have to make hard decisions about how to apportion energy?

Maybe you think everyone should have a home energy storage point? Sure, that's great. Do you think that should be mandatory or voluntary?

Think about the consequences of each of these decisions. Think about what you are asking your neighbors to do. Think about the goals of grid operators and how they might reach them.

Re:Zombie Coal by greglindahl on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:47PM (#23038341)
> Direct Current Inverters can mimic the A/C sine wave, but it's not exactly the same.

Some places use batteries to provide frequency stabilization for cheaper than the spinning metal they used to use. Odd that you would pick one of the most cost-effective use-cases of utility-sized batteries as an example.

Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @11:01PM (#23038670)
I know batteries are for used for quick response grid stabilization, but I've always read that they are worse at maintaining frequency under load.

Do you have a source that talks about frequency stabilization in particular?

Re:Zombie Coal by greglindahl on Thursday April 30, 2020 @11:20PM (#23038764)
The Hornsdale battery in South Australia gets talked about on the news on a regular basis, as in pretty much every frequency stabilization event gets written up with how much better it was than the spinning metal that's also contracted for stabilization in that part of Australia.

BTW you might also note that HVDC and DC-to-DC interconnects are becoming popular. If your theory about batteries being bad for frequency stabilization were true, they'd also be big problems.

Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @11:52PM (#23038951)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current

I'm not an electrical engineer, so all of this has been my lightly informed opinion. I don't have the right words or depth of knowledge to convey my impressions, sorry.

I don't know about big problems, but there are certainly complications and concerns when converting DC to AC at grid scale, as you can see in the Disadvantages portion of the wiki. Sorry I don't have a better source.

I don't think batteries are "bad" for frequency stabilization, I just don't think they're good at it.

With regard to spinning metal, I think you may be referring to flywheel storage? Flywheels do have lower energy density than batteries. I was referring to base load generation by spinning generators.

Re:Zombie Coal by greglindahl on Friday May 01, 2020 @12:06AM (#23039025)
There is no mention of frequency stability in the disadvantages section. Do you have any response to the main point of my comment?

I was referring to the same thing you were with "spinning metal". At the top of this thread, you said "great big spinning metal shafts".

Re:Zombie Coal by JoeAltmaier on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:43PM (#23036509)
And, Methane Hydrates! An enormous reserve of natural gas, estimated 6X all the oil we've ever drilled, waiting to be tapped.
Re:Zombie Coal by pstuart on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:54PM (#23036621)
I hope not. Especially if it means strip mining the ocean floor. Oh, and that CO2 thing as well.

Fossil fuels should be incentivized away as quickly as possible.

Re:Zombie Coal by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:35AM (#23041040)
Of course, but it'll be very attractive at first. So handy for port cities, which are among the largest cities in the world.

And no strip-mining fortunately. Just drilling, pump down some warm water, hydrates dissolve and natural gas starts flowing. Pipeline to land and voila.

Re:Zombie Coal by FlyMoreRockets on Friday May 01, 2020 @09:04AM (#23041569)
The problem is that this slush methane is going to melt with global warming and is a much more potent greenhouse gas than CO2.
Re:Zombie Coal by JoeAltmaier on Saturday May 02, 2020 @08:38AM (#23051397)
There are oceans of it under the seafloor.
Re:Zombie Coal by pstuart on Saturday May 02, 2020 @01:26PM (#23053339)
Yep. Let's leave 'em there.

We need to decarbonize as quickly as possible.

Re:Zombie Coal by floatrock on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:12PM (#23036834)
At what price?

Every time someone says "Fracking gives us 100 years of reserves", they always omit at what price. If most of that is cost-effective at $120 or $140 / barrel, is it really fair to suggest that's a good reserve?

Re:Zombie Coal by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:35AM (#23041047)
Dunno about fracking. But Methane Hydrate is a drilling/warm water deal which seems pretty tame. The Japanese are doing it already (they have no other energy reserves).
Re:Zombie Coal by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 01, 2020 @12:48PM (#23043965)
...and if it leaks, the methane simply cools and forms hydrates again. Which has been happening on the ocean floor for 1B years.
Re:Zombie Coal by makomk on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:59PM (#23036688)
I do wonder how long that lower cost will last if oil implodes. Isn't the current supply of cheap US natural gas a by-product of oil production that may not be viable with current oil prices?
Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:15PM (#23037810)
Not entirely. Some natural gas is co-produced at oil wells, but a lot more is produced from natural gas-only wells.
Re:Zombie Coal by Gibbon1 on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:28PM (#23037897)
Can always use natural gas plants to supplement wind and solar for power generation. And deal with storage later.
Re:Zombie Coal by hedora on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:30PM (#23036385)
It talks a lot about natural gas.

Anyway, storage is getting cheaper. Coal’s dead. By the time current capacity goes off line, renewables will have won.

Even of you don’t believe that, nuclear is a far better option.

No one should be building out new coal capacity.

Re:Zombie Coal by ashtonkem on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:42PM (#23036494)
I would be very enthusiastic to replace our coal base load plants with nuclear. That seems like a very good way to get off of fossil fuels for base load power in the short term. I’d be totally fine with raising my taxes specifically to accomplish that.
Re:Zombie Coal by csours on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:09PM (#23037761)
Natural gas makes sense for the USA, Canada, Mexico, Russia, and maybe a few other countries.

It makes much less sense for other countries with less access to natural gas.

Re:Zombie Coal by FlyMoreRockets on Thursday April 30, 2020 @10:18PM (#23038479)
> Wind doesn't produce energy when the wind doesn't blow.

There is never a time when the wind doesn't blow on some part of the interconnected grid. If the wind stops everywhere at once, there's a much larger problem at hand.