News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by jacquesm on Thursday April 30, 2020 @12:56PM (#23033090)
Why start if you have no intention to see it through? Talks and adoption by the community are a chicken and egg problem, if you don't believe enough in the project to give it staying power then the community is right to not adopt it: they already have a VM for BEAM and it works well. Without an additional selling point 'now in Rust' doesn't cut it.
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by merlinsbrain on Thursday April 30, 2020 @01:59PM (#23033890)
> Why start if you have no intention to see it through

The author had a threshold of good feedback they needed from the community in a certain amount of time. They got the feedback they needed - people aren't interested in it, probably because of the latter part of your comment.

I don't think that's a valid reason to ask why someone started a thing, people start things for a variety of reasons. As far as I am concerned, they saw the development of a reimplementation of solid tech through and learned a lot from it.

> they already have a VM for BEAM and it works well. Without an additional selling point 'now in Rust' doesn't cut it.

This is spot on though.

Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by GolDDranks on Thursday April 30, 2020 @02:16PM (#23034124)
I find this attitude puzzling. If they wanted to start, why not? It seems, according to the comment by the author itself, that they had a lot of fun, and it seemed like an interesting project. So I don't see any reason to back away from it? On the other hand, for the precisely same reason, I see perfectly reasonable that they didn't continue with it. If the fun is gone, why continue?
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by archseer on Thursday April 30, 2020 @07:21PM (#23037431)
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by busterarm on Thursday April 30, 2020 @01:31PM (#23033504)
I see this tendency a lot from the Rust community where there's a lot of "now in Rust" being built, expectations had and then hurt feelings when they're either ignored or shown the door. The community seems to think that "now in Rust" _is_ the selling point. Tools are just tools.

What they don't realize is that they're often building solutions that are looking for problems, rather than solutions to solve problems. It's also vaguely cultish in the approach.

It's a terrific language and there's a lot of learn from it, but I'd like to see it solve real world problems on its own versus try and screw itself into everyone else's.

Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by archseer on Thursday April 30, 2020 @07:16PM (#23037389)
Projects can sometimes be just for fun. I started with two goals: 1) Learn how Erlang internals work 2) Learn Rust (this was the first time I was writing Rust)

After I achieved both of those I decided I'll keep going if there's any interest in the project. There wasn't, so I moved on.

Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by pdimitar on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:12AM (#23040930)
That's a shame. I have a very keen interest in the project and would contribute if I wasn't on the job hunt currently.

Before even checking the GitHub repo, how are your docs? Can an outsider make a deep dive into your code without needing to pester you with questions?

Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by 59nadir on Thursday April 30, 2020 @02:33PM (#23034367)
While it's undeniable the majority of things to come out of Rust are mostly superfluous rewrites of already solid projects (to your point about "now in Rust!" being the selling point) I think it's clear the author in this particular case was just looking into BEAM internals and started a fun project, so I don't think it applies here.

In general, though, I think people ought to consider that if they are putting the language they wrote their project in in the marketing blurb for it (given a more serious project), maybe that indicates that the project itself is of little value to other people. "* Written in Rust" isn't a value proposition, it's just an implementation detail. Make real claims about zero crashes, zero leaks, something actually concrete and it can be scrutinized for real.

Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by chc on Thursday April 30, 2020 @03:37PM (#23035157)
I think you're possibly making a faulty assumption here. You're right that "written in Rust" has no particular value to people who just want to use the thing, but that's not the only perspective people bring to open-source software. When somebody markets a project as "X written in Y," I generally assume they're marketing to people who might want to hack on it, and it is relevant from that perspective.
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by Narishma on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:01PM (#23047398)
Even for users it can be valuable. For example, an Electron application gets an automatic pass from me.
Re:Enigma: Erlang VM Implementation in Rust by merlinsbrain on Thursday April 30, 2020 @03:16PM (#23034916)
Written in X can definitely be a value proposition.

If you are evaluating a tool/lib/etc that moves at a fast pace and your whole shop is extremely fluent in language X there's huge value add to being able to dive in without a context switch to understand how it works, especially when debugging harder problems.

I don't think it applies to _this_ case where we're getting a VM that is _extremely_ battle-tested. Am I going to use a new OS instead of linux in production because someone tried to write an OS in zig? No. Will I congratulate the author for writing an OS in zig? Yes.

If I am looking for a key-value store and two are equivalent in their purported features and stability, I will choose the one that is written in X that my shop is most fluent in.