News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by Jonnax on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:40AM (#23029096)
Honestly Zoom just works how you expect it to.

Other applications do exist and they're bad from a usability perspective.

Google hangouts maxes out my CPU. Teams is a horrible electron app which I'm loathe to use.

So the negatives are that it's unencrypted, traffic might be routed through China sometimes and unknown participants can join if they have the meeting link with password.

For the majority of people they're not too bothered.

I'd argue that security is about having an understanding of the risk and mitigating it accordingly. And for a lot of cases zoom is fine.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by socceroos on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:03AM (#23029225)
We evaluated Jitsi after discovering it during Zoom's security and privacy issues and have been incredibly surprised.

The best part was that none of our more technically challenged members got stuck with joining a meeting (unlike Zoom). I'd say in terms of usability, it's better.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by Matticus_Rex on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:30AM (#23030568)
Jitsi has come a long way in the last six to nine months, though. People who tried it even relatively recently would likely be surprised today (I was). It'll take some time for people to find out how good it has become (assuming it stays that good -- I never take that for granted with things I use for free anymore).
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:34AM (#23030605)
Does not match my experience at all. Jitsi has an awful UI and performance. Noise cancelling seems completely missing, people can’t figure out when they are muted or not (because of the UI) and if you have 20 people on the CPU goes berserk.

In my experience at least and from people I share the calls with, Jitsi is the worst of the bunch but people use it because of privacy reasons.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by socceroos on Thursday April 30, 2020 @07:50PM (#23037634)
Not sure about noise cancellation as we never had an issue, but what you describe about ~20 participants and muting intuitiveness doesn't match our experiences with a wildly tech-illiterate audience.
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by fock on Thursday April 30, 2020 @10:33AM (#23031204)
would you mind explaining what kind of screen you are using/meeting you are in, where 20 people need to/can see and speak to each other within a split-second?
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by Jonnax on Thursday April 30, 2020 @01:56PM (#23033843)
If a product can't do something, whilst it's competition can without issue.

Then it's not really a case of going "but do you really need it?"

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by jcelerier on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:42AM (#23029105)
> Google hangouts maxes out my CPU. Teams is a horrible electron app which I'm loathe to use.

A good example that there are some benefits to using Qt (like Zoom) to make correctly performing apps

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by 72deluxe on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:28AM (#23030545)
I don't think it's Qt. It's another thin window layer, duilib I think?

Their Windows SDK demo pages certainly use it anyway. duilib is here: https://github.com/duilib/duilib

Using the Zoom SDK with its many spelling mistakes and broken English comments, I am sure that a Chinese UI toolkit would be preferable to Zoom, since their development team really does seem to be Chinese.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by jcelerier on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:38AM (#23030640)
It's definitely Qt with QtQuick.

    nm -D -C zoom  | grep Q
https://paste.ofcode.org/vZWguEXM6f7ib6nuCJcMEX
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by 72deluxe on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:58AM (#23030853)
Ah you are on Linux! I am using Windows. That'll explain it!
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by xorfish on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:01AM (#23029217)
Is it really that much better than it's open source alternative jitsi-meet?
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by socceroos on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:04AM (#23029231)
No it's not, I'd say Zoom is demonstrably worse; at least in the experiences of people I've worked with.
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by bachmeier on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:06AM (#23029247)
Zoom performance is crap for me. Routinely poor quality.

Jitsi just works. Seems heavy on resources, but for one-on-one or small groups, way better experience than Zoom.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by solarkraft on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:12AM (#23030404)
Is that not the same thing?
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by power on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:07AM (#23029258)
Zoom traffic is encrypted, just not end-to-end. So your ISP and flatmates can't sniff it but people with access to Zoom servers could
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by ngcc_hk on Thursday April 30, 2020 @07:41AM (#23029787)
Where are those servers?
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by cbm-vic-20 on Thursday April 30, 2020 @09:19AM (#23030467)
The 5.0 client includes an icon that has this information; after starting a meeting, this currently says "You are connected to the Zoom global network via a datacenter in the United States."

Make what you will of that.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by ekianjo on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:31AM (#23030106)
I see you have not used Jitsi. It's not bad.
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by DyslexicAtheist on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:47AM (#23029134)
you're obviously not worried about traffic routed through China might cause IP theft? And you also say Zoom for a lot of cases is fine. Would you say if my company does work for clients in critical technologies (energy plants, telecoms) where research is an expensive upfront investment that it's OK to use Zoom? Or is it more for companies who are only running a web-dev SaaS product where nobody cares about stealing it?

I'm asking as somebody who has found his code stolen by a Chinese colleague working from our Hangzhou office and then published on github after he switched to Huawei (under his real name because that's the amount of f*s they give).

Seriously please don't assume your threat models are portable.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by signal11 on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:04AM (#23029233)
> you're obviously not worried about traffic routed through China might cause IP theft?

Newer versions of Zoom allow you to specify which countries’ data centres are allowed to host your meeting, and also shows which data centres are in use. They’ve also cleaned up their act on encryption.

But yes, a lot of Zoom development occurs in China (700+ employees). But it is US owned. Many other corporations also develop software in China, so I have to ask — where’s the evidence that using Zoom makes you especially vulnerable to being ripped off? Because otherwise it seems a bit FUD-ish.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by DyslexicAtheist on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:16AM (#23029297)
trust only works in retrospect. Zoom has done nothing in its past to deserve that trust.

If one can live with a software that behaves like malware (disabling of a hosts security controls and fake claims about e2ee) than nothing can convince them. Chances are they've committed to Zoom long before and it's now impossible to walk them back to a different reasoning. It's like arguing with a QAnon supporter about reality (Impossible).

Also it's much easier to convince somebody to use product than it's to get them to stop using it. The latter has a cost (pride) but the former is free.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by ftbai on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:44AM (#23029449)
> trust only works in retrospect.

Seems somewhat odd to abide by this kind of principle instead of considering the real changes which we believe have been made, as Zoom seems to have cleaned up their act to some degree in response to the backlash, though you might think not enough.

In any case, if you're being watched, you're not likely to cut corners, and Zoom is being watched. I'm not surprised if the 'suspicious public' effect averages out over all cases to account for the chance that a company is still keeping some unsavory practices under the covers.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by Jonnax on Thursday April 30, 2020 @02:06PM (#23033971)
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/01/23/webex_hid_url_for_r...

Cisco WebEx, secret backdoor that allows websites to run arbitrary code on your machine back in 2017.

Are you going to use it again?

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by DyslexicAtheist on Friday May 01, 2020 @06:57AM (#23040859)
again? who said I ever used it? webex was already rubbish in 2012. the only reason webex is still being cited in 2020 in a whataboutist manner is that there are at least 75K internal CISCO employees forced to continue useing it on a daily basis.
Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by PeterStuer on Thursday April 30, 2020 @05:56AM (#23029188)
If you are worried about traffic routed through China might cause IP theft, are you also worried about traffic routed through Five Eyes countries (US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand)?

After all, they have been caught red handed using their communications interception intelligence gathering for economic favoring of their own companies.

Re:Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeti... by DyslexicAtheist on Thursday April 30, 2020 @06:11AM (#23029277)
> If you are worried about traffic routed through China might cause IP theft, are you also worried about traffic routed through Five Eyes countries (US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand)?

very much so. if you work on projects that take a 2-3 years forward investment on research and based in central Europe (automotive, telecoms, energy) the idea of hosting your source code on github or using google cloud for critical core services is totally out of the question. Some of my clients even booted Atlassin out of their portfolio because Jira was considered a security risk after Australia changed it's laws last year. If you're building web-tech maybe this is fine but that doesn't mean your threat-models are portable to other domains.