News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by gumby on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @09:39PM (#23026619)
I agree, the people who want “the red tape eliminated — lives are at stake” are nuts. Garbage data is garbage data and getting it sooner doesn’t help.

False negatives can cause someone contagious or sick to go out and infect others; false positives can cause unnecessary treatment and take up hospital resources that should have been spent on actual patients.

Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by viggity on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @10:58PM (#23027019)
From what I gather a false positive for an antigen rtPCR is essentially impossible. The primers are extremely specific and can't find something that isn't there.

A false positive for an antibody test is unlikely to take up hospital resources. They admit people to the hospital for symptoms like dyspnea/hypoxia. Not because the patient tested positive on either the antibody or antigen test. The danger in a false positive for an antibody test IgG or IgM, means gives the patient a false sense of security that they've already gotten the virus and are thus immune in the short to medium future.

Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by logicallee on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @11:33PM (#23027158)
>a false positive for an antigen rtPCR is essentially impossiblee. The primers are extremely specific and can't find something that isn't there.

I read somewhere that among the reasons for a false positive would be cross-contamination among samples.

Just because the primers find something in the sample, doesn't mean that that something isn't in fact merely a bit of cross-contamination from another, true positive, sample.

Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by xscott on Thursday April 30, 2020 @03:25AM (#23028324)
I was watching this video earlier tonight:

https://youtu.be/Vat-PKdQ13A?t=30

That looked like some really sloppy lab technique, and I hope that's not how it is really done in practice. If real tests are done by hand like this, with distractions, open air, and no mask on the technicians, it's easy to imagine false positives.

Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by tinus_hn on Thursday April 30, 2020 @07:32AM (#23029735)
The South Korea ‘reinfection’ story turned out to be based on false positives.
Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by acqq on Thursday April 30, 2020 @08:09AM (#23029960)
> turned out to be based on false positives.

I believed it was based on false negatives in previous PCR tests?

It's also a question of understanding what the test actually means. The test doesn't (and can't) claim "this patient is cured" but only "when analyzing this specific sample taken from this patient, no significant trace of virus could be confirmed."

Re:Roche CEO's says some Covid-19 antibody tests are a disaster by tinus_hn on Thursday April 30, 2020 @10:03AM (#23030889)
No, the patients were cured but later portions of the virus were again detected. These portions turned out to be inactive.

Of course it is possible to define the test in such a way it is 100% effective. This removes the relation to the Covid-19 disease though so then the test is useless.