If you can keep the users for 1 year, you'll have made more than the $12 cap you would have and, if you don't, at least you don't have the support headache of having to deal with a customer who bought in at the minimum for life -- non-paying users at this price tier go away. Plus, anybody willing to break out their wallets at all are likely to have little qualm over $1 a month.
Also, with a fairly regular income stream, it'll allow you to plan your expenditures more reliably, so budgeting for things like employees, server space, etc will be easier to plot out cost vs income.
The practical result is that the upgrade becomes progressively cheaper (since the signup fee is deductible from the first year's subscription)
I bookmark so I can look at something later, and the unpredictable perishability of the web defeats that purpose. Archiving snatches victory from the jaws of defeat. :-)
I would like to see tag hierarchies à la del.icio.us, if you were bored and wanted to implement them.