Early exercise.
Do I have this right or am I misunderstanding the scenario?
Edit: Apparently the Canadian portion is important - US options are wack and work totally differently to normal options!
Not quite. Say one has a vesting schedule of 100/year for 5 years. Early exercise would allow one to "purchase" 500 shares on day 1, with the caveat that they be returned if the vesting schedule isn't met, e.g. if the employee leaves on day 2.
> US options are wack and work totally differently to normal options
"Normal" options, European-style options, make up the minority of instruments described by the term "options". Stock options are negotiated instruments. They vary wildly from case to case.
Certain amount of consolidation occurs in different jurisdictions as a result of tax codes. But in a global scheme, early exercise is entirely normal for employee stock options.
Aside from that weirdness a share in a company is yours and I'm quite skeptical you could be forced to sell it back to the company - what _is_ common is that the grantor will reserve the right of first purchase. If you decide to sell your vested and exercised options to a third party (say a random friend) you cannot legally transact that without first offering the companies the ability to purchase it at the price of their choosing.
The result of this is that vested and exercised shares are usually a terrible idea in nearly every scenario - except when that action might result in some tax benefits from long term investment[1].
1. Some jurisdictions waive capital gains taxes on sales of stock if the shares were held for a "long" time usually several years.