News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by akvadrako on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:01PM (#23010517)
Federal guaranteed student loans have nothing to do with UBI. It's hard to argue that college fees would have gone up so much if the government just gave a fixed $10000/year loan to every student-age citizen and let them spend it on whatever they want.

In an important way they are opposite: UBI incentivizes price discovery; government backed college loans decentivize it.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by dctoedt on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:38PM (#23010915)
> Federal guaranteed student loans have nothing to do with UBI.

If you say so.

> It's hard to argue that college fees would have gone up so much if the government just gave a fixed $10000/year loan to every student-age citizen and let them spend it on whatever they want.

Really? I find it very easy to imagine, since IIRC student loans can be spent not only on tuition but on living expenses — and it seems to be possible to spend it on anything you want, even though you're not supposed to do that. [1] But I'm out of touch in that area, so my experience could be out of date.

The NPR piece that I cited above discussed research indicating that for-profit college tuition costs were strongly influenced by the availability of guaranteed student loans.

> UBI incentivizes price discovery

I suppose that's possible. But analogously, the availability of employer-provided health insurance seems to disincentivize price discovery.

[1] https://studentloanhero.com/featured/what-can-i-spend-studen...

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by akvadrako on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:44PM (#23010986)
> the availability of employer-provided health insurance seems to disincentivize price discovery.

That I certainly agree with.