News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by dllthomas on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:24PM (#23002300)
That seems to rely on an assumption that there's no variation in amount or quality of job searching effort, above the minimum required, which might be influenced. It also assumes inability to fake a job search, or sabotage an otherwise legitimate one, which might let an individual so intending to fall below the required minimum. The latter seems questionable, the first seems wrong.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by sanderjd on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @12:21AM (#23003326)
I feel like there's a lot of pedantry in this thread and this topic in general. The point is that people not wanting to work is just so very far from our problem that it is ridiculous to see people harping on it so much. People aren't working because they were furloughed or laid off because aggregate demand is way down, it has nothing to do with the unemployment benefits they're getting. The vast vast majority of those people just want their boss to call them and say "good news! our customers are back! see you tomorrow!".
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by j7ake on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:18AM (#23004371)
Of course we are all speculating on what people want or will do in this situation.

But take a hypothetical continuum of unemployment benefits. At which point will your thesis that "people want to work but are unable" switch to "people aren't working because they're being paid way more to not work? The switch will probably be binary at the individual level but will look like a continuum when looking at the population level.

Individuals will of course respond differently depend on the specific contexts of their life. I think in the end a quantity that will matter will be the ratio of unemployment benefits to old job salary. Other factors such as job satisfaction in previous job will contribute to the variance.

Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by sanderjd on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @08:24AM (#23006287)
My actual point is that this is an ideologically driven distraction, not a real policy debate.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by dllthomas on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @12:31PM (#23008666)
I was speaking just to the argument made by dragonwriter that, because something is banned, the possibility has no impact. If you think this was motivated by an ideological objection to government assistance... well, you're mistaken, because I don't have one of those. I can't speak to anything up-thread.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by sanderjd on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:24PM (#23010132)
Ok you're right, maybe I have two points: I think this distraction is driven by ideology and partly maintained by (or taking advantage of) pedantry. It is far too tempting for logically-minded pedants to say "but you can clearly see what the numbers show", which is true, but is not a useful point except as further fuel for the distraction.

The real problem we're going to have is people struggling to find jobs as demand ramps back up slowly in fits and starts. This whole conversation is an attempt to portray those struggling people as the problem. It is indirection, like in a magic trick. And the pedantic "well actually"s are falling for the trap.

It's a real bummer because it's definitely going to work, which is going to cause us to underinvest in unemployment insurance over time, which is going to make this even more painful than it was already going to be. It would just be nice if people could see that they're being played.

Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by dllthomas on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @06:28PM (#23012908)
Calling out significant flaws is not pedantry. Defending arguments because they are "on your side", irrespective of merit, is destructive to the kind of reasoned discussion I value on this site (certainly it's not always available, but let's aim for more of it, yeah?). And I actually think that repeating obviously flawed arguments does the other side's work, turning away the undecided - especially on a site like this.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by sanderjd on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:00PM (#23013167)
For some topics that are intended purely as distractions, the whole goal is just to get people talking about it. So mission accomplished.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by dllthomas on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:57PM (#23013620)
Cura te ipsum, but if that's your remaining issue I won't distract further.
Re:The San Francisco Bay Area shelter-in-place order is bein... by sanderjd on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @10:36AM (#23019744)
Indeed you're right! Plus I enjoyed looking that up :)