Please support your local third place, like a hackerspace or a non-profit community centre: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
Highly ecudated != bright mind
I think it is because nowadays you can communicate with other bright minds instantly, as long as you can find them in the mazes of the internet.
Back then you had to be physically with them in the same space. Today you don't have that physical limitation.
But to be honest, due to sheer curiosity - i would love to try such coffee house, but unless we discover a time machine i doubt it will ever happen.
Maybe, but those people aren’t really interacting with each other or sharing ideas in a way that isn’t aligned with their personal or professional goals. The cafe of yore was a melting pot of people and ideas; the contemporary cafeteria is far more functional and teleological.
Maybe it was my fault by using the term ‘brightest minds’, but intelligence or education level is also not really the main draw. Certainly the revolutionary artists of the late 1800s weren’t the most academically educated ones.
Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago.
I think what you're yearning for is really the bourgeois culture of high-minded intellectuals participating in exclusive clubs rather than facilitating good discourse between intelligent people. Access to the latter nowadays is thankfully much easier than it was in the past.