News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by lgleason on Monday April 27, 2020 @11:44AM (#22996915)
My mother went in for a fusion on her spine and came out with MRSA and died from it. In this case the cure was worse than the disease.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by ebg13 on Monday April 27, 2020 @11:53AM (#22996995)
Your situation is tragic and I'm saddened by the loss, but fatal infection is orthogonal to the subject of the article. MRSA infection is a procedural error not caused by the implant itself.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by kube-system on Monday April 27, 2020 @12:13PM (#22997185)
The article discusses infection risk. Infection risk is an inherent part of the total risk associated with any medical procedure. It is not separable -- you cannot use an implant if it is not implanted.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by Balanceinfinity on Monday April 27, 2020 @12:23PM (#22997284)
Sadly, horribly, that is now a risk with every major procedure - but at least it's a known risk that the patient can choose to accept when the underlying condition is not life threatening. Devices that don't work properly and haven't been properly reviewed by the FDA are risks the patient can't reasonably evaluate.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by kube-system on Monday April 27, 2020 @12:39PM (#22997424)
> Sadly, horribly, that is now a risk with every major procedure

Infection always has and likely always will be a risk when you open up a human. Evaluating, understanding, and measuring those risks is the only way we can begin to mitigate them.

On the bright side, recent medical technology has also brought us a lot of minimally or non-invasive procedures. Those generally have much lower (sometimes almost zero) risks of infection.

Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by unsrsly on Monday April 27, 2020 @01:49PM (#22998122)
MRSA is known to "hide" from the immune system on indwelling hardware. Often, part of the treatment for MRSA infection is to explant the hardware (source control). So even though MRSA infection is not a "device failure," having a device in place is a major factor in whether the body can clear the infection. Also, it's probably rare, but an implant can directly cause an infection if there's a flaw in the sterilization process the manufacturer uses.
Re:Do some surgical implants do more harm than good? by rsync on Monday April 27, 2020 @02:34PM (#22998567)
"My mother went in for a fusion on her spine and came out with MRSA and died from it."

This tragic and inexcusable outcome is doubly so because even a "successful" implantation of a spinal fusion has, essentially, zero chance of improving pain or mobility outcomes[1] and patients would be much better off pursuing a moderate, graduated course of walking-as-physical-therapy.

I'm sorry that your mother died.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinal_fusion#Effectiveness