Re:Was there PTSD in the ancient or medieval world?
by Spooky23 on Monday April 27, 2020 @10:00AM
(#22995878)
The poster was trying to make a point that I think stands even if there are some technical definitional issues.
Roman history is long and practices vary. I don't think that you can critically look at the campaigns to conquer and pacify Gaul or Carthage without walking away with the understanding that mass killing (or enslavement) wasn't a tool wielded by the Romans.
Re:Was there PTSD in the ancient or medieval world?
by rsynnott on Monday April 27, 2020 @03:15PM
(#22998964)
Oh, sure; they did awful things. I'm just not sure that decimation is reasonable evidence for "Likewise, ancient culture and justice must be almost incomprehensible to us."; the Nazis did far, far worse, say.
For that matter, their behavior in Gaul isn't evidence of it either; again, we unfortunately have many recent parallels.
This is incorrect. Decimation was a form of military discipline, not civilian, and it was _extremely_ rare for most of Rome's history. It was usually used for mass desertion. Thousands of people were executed for individual desertion during WW1, so you could argue that it's not THAT exotic a punishment.
The Roman Empire _did_ do various nasty things to rebellious provinces (Judea is particularly notable), but again, really nothing that we haven't seen in 20th century wars, unfortunately.