I'm not sure how the GPL covers a particular packaging configuration of a build of something which has GPL'd source. Sure the source can be redistributed, but the binary possibly not. In practice, this is not much of a distinction because you can build the package from the source, but in this case the source probably doesn't have anything in it saying "Apple has built this source code into OSX." What Apple has done is essentially building a binary of MacRuby and installing in a location on the filesystem of a MacOSX Lion install. None of which you could claim that the GPL allows you to by-pass an NDA over.
Re:Hey Apple, Please Be Nice and Share MacRuby
by rbanffy on Monday March 07, 2011 @08:56PM
(#2299514)
MacRuby is under the Ruby License. I am not sure it prohibits distributions of binaries without source. If, however, Apple decided to include the latest and greatest version of, say, bash, they would be required to give you redistribution rights along with the source. You could, then, redistribute it (thus giving informations about the next OSX) without violating the NDA.
If Apple forbids you to get the source of their GPL'ed parts and passing this source on to others, they are in violation of the GPL and their own right to distribute it is voided.
Re:Hey Apple, Please Be Nice and Share MacRuby
by pyre on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:39AM
(#2301233)
Apparently you didn't read what I wrote. Apple cannot prevent you form getting the source code, but the source code does not include information like "the binary will be installed to this location and will be considered a Mac OSX private framework." When something is considered a 'private framework' in OSX it's primarily an install location which does not change the source code as install location is usually a build-time option. Build-time options are not something that is covered by the GPL.
For instance, when Apple gives you a copy of Lion it is obligated to give you access to the source of every GPL'ed part of it and you must be free to redistribute it or modified versions. If their NDA prohibits this, they have no right to distribute any GPL'ed code in the first place because they are in violation of the terms of the GPL.