When Muddy Waters first put out the tweet, were they:
(a) planning an investigation of NMC, and the market validated their suspicions when the stock dropped?
(b) planning an investigation of another firm, but then when NMC stock dropped thought "Hey, did we just freak out a bunch of in-the-know traders that something fishy is going on with NMC?" and then start the NMC investigation based on that? If this is the right answer, what was the other firm they were planning to investigate?
(c) not really planning an investigation of any firm in particular, but threw out that tweet in the hopes that someone would bite, and when NMC traders "bit" by selling, that's when they started their investigation?
https://twitter.com/muddywatersre/status/1159009866020618241
Pretty amazing that they went through and took a look at all the companies whose stock prices dropped from Aug 6-7th on LSE as a sort of "business development" opportunity.
It's like the old trope where the accuser says to a group of people "I know what you did!", and then everyone in the group confesses to various misdeeds even though the accuser was only talking about one of them.
In this case they just mentioned the Company is listed in LSE, and the traders figured out by themselves who was it.
Because they need to build their short positions before making everything public.
In this case maybe they lost profits if the market adjusted before they finish setting up their positions
That's the most interesting 'event study', as it were, I've heard of since the Challenger or Alchian's nuclear bomb market study.
It's amazing the things that the market 'knows'. I sometimes wish that event studies could track down the specific traders responsible and understand what exactly they know and how they learned it, because it otherwise is such voodoo.