News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did Slack win out over IRC? (2018) by mstudio on Sunday April 26, 2020 @10:11AM (#22987268)
This article is comparing apples to oranges. IRC is a protocol, Slack is a client/app that uses protocols (one of which used to be IRC). Many IRC clients, although beloved by some users, are rough around the edges.

In my opinion, Slack has "won" over other clients because of UX: it's extremely easy to sign-up, understand, and use productively. Plus, even large orgs (ours included), can use the free version if they're OK with having chat history disappear after a few days/weeks.

Re:Why did Slack win out over IRC? (2018) by apple4ever on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:21PM (#22988589)
Slack made the process easy, and with emojis and slash commands, fun and useful.

I think another benefit to slack is you can come back to it and see the history. IRC is ephemeral unless you stick to a single device and leave it running. That's impossible for a mobile phone.

It frustrates me that some large projects (ex Ansible) who insist on all discussions there, and explicitly ignore things like GitHub issues.

Re:Why did Slack win out over IRC? (2018) by Spivak on Sunday April 26, 2020 @05:41PM (#22990513)
I am in no way saying that this isn't a barrier to entry (and if we're honest I think that barrier is an intentional choice) but you're supposed run a bouncer/logger and just connect your client to that.

It's always weird to me that IRC didn't evolve like email with something like IMAP.

Re:Why did Slack win out over IRC? (2018) by 1337shadow on Sunday April 26, 2020 @06:37PM (#22990921)
> another benefit to slack is you can come back to it and see the history

As long as you pay the price.