The whole point of semantic versioning is to guarantee breaking changes are expressed through major versions. If you break your package’s compatibility and bump the version to 1.2.1 instead of 2.0.0 then people absolutely should be upset.
This is the germane point in this incident.
The parent comment mentions that SemVer "guarantee[s] breaking changes are expressed through major versions". This is a common misperception about SemVer. That "guarantee" is purely hypothetical and doesn't apply to the real world where humans make mistakes.
The OP `is-promise` issue is an example of the real world intruding on this guarantee. The maintainers clearly didn't intend to break things but they did because everybody makes mistakes
Which points to the actual value proposition of SemVer: by obeying these rules, consumers of your package will know your _intention_ with a particular changeset. If the actual behavior of that changeset deviates from the SemVer guidelines (e.g. breaking behavior in a patch bump), then it's a bug and should be fixed accordingly.
Back to the parent's point about locking dependency version— I would add that you should also store a copy of your dependencies in a safe location that you control (aka vendoring) if anything serious depends upon your application being continually up and running.
That is: "^1.2.1" shouldn't be a bad default relative to "1.2.1"; you generally want to be able to pull in non-breaking security updates automatically, for what I hope are obvious reasons, and if that goes sideways then the blame should be entirely on the package maintainer for violating version semantics, not on the package/dependency manager for obeying version semantics.
I don't have much of an opinion on this for Node.js, but the Ruby and Elixir ecosystems (among those of many, many other languages which I've used in recent years) have similar conventions, and I don't seem to recall nearly as many cases of widely-used packages blatantly ignoring semantic versioning. Then again, most typically require the programmer to be explicit about whether or not to allow sub-minor automatic version updates for a given dependency, last I checked (e.g. you edit a configuration file and use the build tool to pull the dependencies specified in that file, as opposed to the build tool itself updating that file like npm apparently does).
Yes, this is by design. If this weren't the case, the ecosystem would be an absolute minefield of non-updated transitive dependencies with unpatched security issues.
And it's even worse in cargo, because specifying "1.2.1" means the same thing as "^1.2.1".
I think the real evil here is that by default npm does not encourage pinned dependency versions.
If I npm install is-promise I'll get something like "^1.2.1" in my package.json not the exact "1.2.1". This means that the next time someone installs my CLI I don't know exactly what code they're getting (unless I shrinkwrap which is uncommon).
In other stacks having your dependency versions float around is considered bad practice. If I want to go from depending on 1.2.1 to 1.2.2 there should be a commit in my history showing when I did it and that my CI still passed.
I think we miss the forest for the trees when we get mad about Node devs taking small dependencies. If they had pinned their version it would have been fine.