Another most serious study based on over 1500 hospital workers found that cloth masks let through over 95% of particles.
That more serious study was done in 2015 but there's no reason to think it would not still be correct.
vs
"Cloth masks tested on 4 people reduces virus from coughing by 70%"
If that is the only study being citied to go against public health officers I'm be skeptical. If cloth masks work it should be feasible to do a larger study and prove it with a high degree of confidence.
Think about hand sanitizers: some advertise 99.9% reduction, which is "millions become thousands", bare-minimum levels of actually reducing risk of infection from an exposure. 70% is like "millions become fewer millions"
Besides, that's hardly the only variable at play. The virus doesn't spread on the atmosphere only by dispersion, so the particles energy is relevant. It doesn't spread in only in dry particles, so that ratio is relevant, as is the efficiency in blocking the larger wet particles. And it doesn't spread only by coughing, so the efficiency on normal breathing and speaking is important too.
Also, we don't need completely effective barriers for people at the street, this is not ebola. We just need to reduce the virus spread by ~60%.
The one thing we know is that the countries where people use masks are having an easier time fighting the virus. We don't really know if it's because of the masks, but it's a good bet.
"I have reanalysed the Korean data using the suggested replacement value of half the LOD and the results don’t change very much, suggesting a reduction of 70% of virus particles when using cloth masks."
And it starts with...
"His key claim is that “cotton masks reduce virus emitted duringcoughing by 96%”, citing a recent South Korean study."
So 70% isn't as good as 96%, but it seems like that's still a decent number. Or am I reading this wrong?