News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by gaius on Monday March 07, 2011 @06:36AM (#2296812)
Yeah, this is a fallacy many people hold. We are not here to "write programs". We are here to solve people's problems, a program is just a means to do that. That's what you're really measured on, how many and how difficult the problems you solve are. If you can solve a problem not with code but wth say updating the documentation, or running a training class, then as a programmer that's the right thing to do.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by Locke1689 on Monday March 07, 2011 @06:47AM (#2296827)
It can actually hurt if you're really good at or really like programming because it can sometimes lead to unnecessary programming. A common example of this is writing a small script to automate something that would have actually taken less time to just perform manually the one or two times you have to do it.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by mgkimsal on Monday March 07, 2011 @06:55AM (#2296838)
Agreed, except you need the wisdom to know when you truly will never ever have to do that task again (nor anyone else) vs when you think you only need to do it once. There's value in having something scripted that you end up needing to come back to months later. I also know I would have preferred setup steps to be scripted on projects I've taken over, vs apparently just hand-entering SQL.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by JonnieCache on Monday March 07, 2011 @09:51AM (#2297252)
This is why you put the script on github and blog about it, that way there's a chance the script could save millions of times the amount of time it took to write.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by Darmani on Monday March 07, 2011 @07:12AM (#2296873)
But then you run a risk of not automating things you should have automated, which is already much more common.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by billybob on Monday March 07, 2011 @01:08PM (#2298042)
On the other hand, if you have to do it one or two times a month, you should write a script. It prevents future mistakes on your part, and makes the task a lot easier to hand off to someone else, because you're guaranteed to record all the necessary steps.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by wmat on Monday March 07, 2011 @09:44AM (#2297230)
This is exactly my job, that of a 'Business Systems Analyst' at a big insurance company. I spend most of my time refining requirements with business stakeholders until I can document a set of atomic tasks. This documentation, generally referred to as a 'Business Requirements Specification' gets passed along to the developer who then writes a 'Technical Specification' detailing the implementation of each business requirement. One of my primary goals is to remove any guesswork or questions from the developers scope, such that they can focus clearly on the implementation of the solution. In all of the enterprise level development jobs I've worked, the developer is not expected to interact with the business at all. The overhead for simple development sky rockets, but that's a reasonable trade off to meet regulatory requirements such as Sarbannes Oxley, etc.
Re:What a programmer does for a living by cubicle67 on Monday March 07, 2011 @05:55PM (#2299067)
A BA is one of those jobs I'd always thought would suit me until, in a previous life, I spent a few years working as a developer for Big Co. there we had a whole team of BAs and god were they hopeless. One of the worst things to happen to the development process.

the idea seemed to be that programmers are code monkeys; don't let them think, lets define exactly what they need to produce and get them to do exactly that. Then get a team of people to act as intermediaries between the business and the devs.

Geat idea except for: the BAs were passionless and didn't give a damn about anything other than getting the job 'done'. They didn't really understand the business at all. Most (almost all) of the many reams of documentation they produced was useless. They had no programming background, and no ability to anticipate edge cases, missing cases or anything really.

Sorry, but my limited exposure to business analysts has left me with not much more than a mix of contempt/ambivalence for the role.