News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why not “Why not WireGuard?” by Spooky23 on Thursday April 23, 2020 @06:18PM (#22962218)
I agree the original article was really dumb, and sounded like it was written by an enterprise network guy who has only worked with and been trained by big vendors.

That said, the fatal flaw of Wireguard is the crypto model. Nobody who interacts with the US government, regulated US industries, or some F500 will be able to use it because of the fixed algorithm choice, which isn’t possibly FIPS 140-2 validatable. You’ll always need that Cisco/Pulse/whatever box.

That may be a feature for some, but it kneecaps the possibility of it being as ubiquitous as it might be otherwise.

Re:Why not “Why not WireGuard?” by tptacek on Thursday April 23, 2020 @08:13PM (#22963182)
It's a trap, because your options boil down to:

(a) Using FIPS cryptography, which is inferior, to placate the USG.

(b) Using best-practices cryptography, and being incompatible with some places that mandate FIPS.

(c) Supporting both FIPS and non-FIPS cryptography, which creates handshake bugs and gives you lowest-common-denominator security.

I think you can reasonable argue that (a) and (b) are both superior to (c); I think WireGuard made the right choice here.

In the long run, for enterprise environments, I don't think this much matters. Even with FIPS cryptography, stodgy enterprises won't adopt WireGuard until it becomes so prevalent elsewhere that they have to, simply because IPSEC has more standardization. So the WireGuard task is simply to make it so prevalent everywhere else that stodgy enterprises no long have a vote.

Re:Why not “Why not WireGuard?” by microcolonel on Thursday April 23, 2020 @07:55PM (#22963058)
I mean, we can just update the legislation to accept the competent ciphersuites, or the government can publish that once-in-a-century whitepaper where they demonstrate that DJB has been a brilliant CIA shill this whole time and the nothing-up-my-sleeve numbers have something up their sleeves.

Like, I get that that is not likely to happen, but the resistance of the state to competence is not an excuse for resistance to it outside the state.