Moloch is a serious open source project, run by serious people who care about network security. They published their code under an open source license, showing off just how confident they are that it is solid. You can use this project to inspect packets on your network, you can learn how they built it and become a valuable network security engineer with a job somewhere finding people trying to hack in to your site. You can propose modifications to make this even better (and if your code is good enough, it will get accepted and used by security teams around the world). Or you could focus on the name they chose and the name of the company at the time this was published.
I'd seize the opportunity to talk tech and focus on network security. Infosec jobs pay better than brand marketing jobs.
Then I see projects like this, or Jaeger/OpenZipkin, or Chaos Monkey, and I'm simply inspired. Much like listening to a killer record.
I don't spend time feeling sorry for myself because an ancient, somewhat esoteric proper noun was used to describe the project.
None of the critical comments were particularly strident ('bent out of shape').
Your comment might as well be about itself.
Oh but now I’ve contributed to it as well. Uh oh...
"Look and despair, yo!"
To be anti-grandfathered ?
A lot of people do care about what things (living or not) are named and even how, sometimes and attach a lot of emotional value to it for a good reason.
Quoting Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_naming#Principles
- They strategically distinguish the product from its competitors by conveying its unique positioning.
- They hold appeal for the product’s target audience.
- They imply or evoke a salient brand attribute, quality or benefit.
- They allow companies to bond with their customers to create loyalty.
- They have a symbolic association that fortifies the image of a company or a product to the consumers.
- They help motivate customers to buy the product.
I'm sorry but claiming that an uncomfortable discussion on a project's name is not the response one wants to see is exactly what turns this into an echo chamber? To be noted how discussion on a product's technical merits isn't mutually exclusive to discussion on its naming. Both could easily be had, and both have their places, because I don't particularly think either is off-topic. In fact, a previous news.yc thread on this product brought up a similar line of discussion. I guess one could argue the discussion is counter-productive in a technical forum, but I don't think one should avoid it just because... unless the community rules explicitly state so. Technical people aren't robots, at least not yet.
I'm arguing that the naming of a thing matters less than the efficacy of the thing itself. Doubly so in a hacker-oriented forum.
As for the echo-chamber, that's a classic human fallacy which I think is magnified by the centralization of content aggregation into heavily personalized "newsfeed" style design choices perpetuated by major players.
The epidemic of "outrage culture," or "offense culture" is something comedians and free thinkers have been discussing for awhile, and I think is underpinning of my personal frustrations.
-----
"This idea of "I'm offended". I've got news for you - I'm offended by a lot of things too. Where do I send my list? Life is offensive. Get in touch with your outer adult, and grow up, and move on."
-----
Post, comment, discuss as y'all like, right? That's the beauty of the format. I'm simply one of ∞.
The folks in the community here are brilliant, and the reasonable ones are off doing something meaningful, whereas I'm here arguing for practice, basically.
I’m a rational guy to the best of my ability, but FWIW I would avoid using this project solely because of its name (just the thought of that name evokes a sick feeling to me - that’s how strong the negative association is... I won’t explain why as this isn’t an appropriate venue for that).
We are human, and sometimes visceral responses can’t be ignored regardless of their irrationality.
I could invoke Godwin’s law to give a more universal example of words with negative associations, but I’ll refrain.
Like it or not, people will have internal reactions to things—and I for one would prefer if others let me know if they found a project name I chose to be difficult in some way.
excuse me...w-what?
Why get bent out of shape over the name of a software project? It's virtually a meaningless factor in day-to-day life.
What about hearing phrases "Sacrificing a Chicken to Moloch," the "spirit cooking" culture and related symbolism rampant in elite political circles? Shouldn't we be more interested in that?
Lots of low-hanging fruit to pick, I guess. Someday I might unlock the "downvote" ability on this platform. Until then my opinions don't carry weight here. Also, uhh who decides the "threshold" for downvoting? Hint: nobody knows. [0]
This platform has become more of an echo chamber than a host of rational discussion based on merit. I suppose that's a problem with growth.
There's a lot of conversation around "Moloch" as a name and the subsequent emotional responses... but not a lot of discussion about the tech at-hand. And it's a repost.
Where's the value?
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
Edit: while this is high-ranking comment, I'd point out that if I had the ability I would have just downvoted the comments I didn't like. Take that for whatever it's worth.