News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magic Leap reportedly slashes jobs and steps away from co... by hinkley on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @02:27PM (#22948652)
I'm having trouble thinking of times when I felt more demoralized as a developer than when the sales team has made promises that simply defied the laws of information theory, and then wondered why we couldn't just work harder to fix the problem.

I mean, technically, capital I Innovation often comes in finding a way to do something without violating the laws of physics, but that's how company origin stories are written. You don't schedule that on the project roadmap "And then a miracle occurs" style.

During a particularly memorable instance of this situation, I recall reading a story by someone suggesting that you can close this feedback loop with peer reviews across functional units. Marketing reviewed product management, product management reviewed development, development reviewed QA, and QA reviewed...

And this is the kicker: QA reviewed marketing. So if marketing sold something that was undefinable and thus untestable, they got an earful from QA. No bonus for you.

I fantasized about that over countless cups of coffee with coworkers for the next year or two.

Re:Magic Leap reportedly slashes jobs and steps away from co... by Twirrim on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @02:47PM (#22948857)
> I'm having trouble thinking of times when I felt more demoralized as a developer than when the sales team has made promises that simply defied the laws of information theory, and then wondered why we couldn't just work harder to fix the problem.

Years ago, when "Web 2.0" was only just taking off as a buzz word ('07-'08?), Marketing came to my team to demand we make sure our shared web hosting platform be "Web 3.0", so that we were ahead of the curve. That was a super fun conversation, in a "hitting your head against a brick wall" way. You'd think that people in marketing would understand the concept of a buzz word.

Re:Magic Leap reportedly slashes jobs and steps away from co... by didibus on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:32PM (#22951659)
I know that feeling, but at the same time, if Marketing makes the sales, and the customers are happy, the plan is working. And I have definitely seen cases where constraints bred creativity, and the ridiculous promises of marketing actually did force the devs to be more creative and sometimes spark some miracle, aka, some really creative and innovative approach to the problem. It also often falls flat, but that's the gamble I guess.
Re:Magic Leap reportedly slashes jobs and steps away from co... by hinkley on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:33PM (#22952579)
That is management's job, not Marketing. For one, there is no trust relationship that can support that sort of act, but what's the point of project management if the marketing people get to decide the roadmap not only by themselves but individually?