Re:Venezuela's squatter skyscrapers; as the country declines
by michaelchisari on Sunday March 06, 2011 @02:48PM
(#2294851)
I'm not interested in "correcting" for demographics. You can't simply remove 25% of the population because you find statistics inconvenient.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Venezuela's squatter skyscrapers; as the country declines
by yummyfajitas on Sunday March 06, 2011 @03:08PM
(#2294892)
Hypothetical: if teacher A has a class of poor black students, and teacher B has a class of rich asian students, shall we directly compare test scores? If teacher A's students perform 1 stddev worse than teacher B's, shall we fire teacher A for poor performance?
If you don't want to do it for teachers, why do it for educational systems?
Re:Venezuela's squatter skyscrapers; as the country declines
by michaelchisari on Sunday March 06, 2011 @03:30PM
(#2294948)
I prefer not to reduce complex, intersecting systems to oversimplified hypotheticals.
Re:Venezuela's squatter skyscrapers; as the country declines
by yummyfajitas on Sunday March 06, 2011 @04:45PM
(#2295106)
Huh? You want to ignore all factors relevant to the question except one (school quality), I try to introduce a second factor, and I'm oversimplifying?
Please go look up the definition of "simple".
Re:Venezuela's squatter skyscrapers; as the country declines
by michaelchisari on Sunday March 06, 2011 @05:12PM
(#2295176)
I'm sure that's how you see it, but the fact is, that the OP posited the idea that unions were incompatible with a healthy education system. There are simply too many counter-examples to that.
Further, you've pushed the conversation into a discussion about race and class by way of an abstract hypothetical. From your posting history, I'm not really interested in having such a complex discussion with you.