Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by SilasX on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:27PM
(#22947313)
Really? You mean, even an existing (approved) bank can't just one day decide to stop lending and revert to narrow functions?
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:28PM
(#22947326)
They could, but would see a reduction in income by doing so, therefore an unlikely occurrence. I don’t see many banks willingly walk away from low risk income.
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by SilasX on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:41PM
(#22947459)
Yes, but you were saying that the impediment was a legal one. I'm asking if that's really true, given that a(n approved) bank can just elect not to provide some services. Surely that can't be illegal.
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:44PM
(#22947505)
I’m speaking about starting a new bank, and obtaining a bank license to do so.
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by SilasX on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:56PM
(#22947627)
You were speaking about the general possibility of running narrow banking. Whether it is a new bank or existing bank doesn't matter to that point, so you can't dismiss the possibility of an existing bank doing it and thereby claim it's impossible because a new bank couldn't get a license on that premise.
"Narrow banking is impossible."
'What if you did it this way?'
"I'm not talking about that, I'm talking about the impossible ways."
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:01PM
(#22947684)
I apologize if my citation and my explanation were not clear enough to convey the concept in my original comment ("Federal Reserve will not issue banking licenses to allow new banking entrants to operate as narrow banks").
Re:Small business rescue earned banks $10B in fees
by SilasX on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:14PM
(#22947846)
That point was plenty clear, and I was not disputing it, so no need for an apology. The more relevant point here is whether narrow banking is legal at all, and I was trying to bring the discussion over to that point.
If your point was merely to cite some non-blocking barrier to narrow banking, than I don't really see why you brought it up. If you want to apologize, apologize for being technically correct at the expense of providing insight.
A narrow bank does not require lending to service deposit accounts. It doesn't even need to pay interest to account holders. It simply needs to accept, store, and distribute fiat on the behalf of its customers via ACH, debit, and credit processing networks. Think prepaid card with no fees and no overdraft capability.
The Federal Reserve is culpable in that it will not approve banking licenses for narrow banks [1], as it challenges the business model of existing entrenched banking organizations. Can you build a narrow bank without getting the Fed to sign off? That is a conversation I would be interested in having over a cup of coffee.
[1] https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights...