Re:How Optimizely Improved Facebook Ad Retargeting Cost by 83%
by nrmitchi on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @01:17PM
(#22936989)
While I'm sure the methods in here are valuable, the initial claim of 83% seems suspect.
> After launching the Adaptive Audience campaign, CPA for our technical audience went from $34.47 for general remarketing to $18.80 for the targeted remarketing via adaptive audiences, so an 83% overall improvement for CPA for our technical audience – which is a huge win!
This seems like a misleading way to phrase this. When I hear 83% improvement from $34.47, I expect a 83% ($28.61) drop, ie, 34.47 * (1 - 0.83) = 5.86.
This is more reasonably a (34.47 - 18.80) / 34.47 = 45% drop. Still impressive, but not the same.
Is it really standard to express your improvement in these terms? This would make it trivial to have a >100% drop in cost, which is clearly wrong.
Re:How Optimizely Improved Facebook Ad Retargeting Cost by 83%
by remarkEon on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @01:05PM
(#22936860)
It's always great to reduce costs where you can.
It's not always great, in my humble opinion, if this results in my being inundated with more ads on the internet. I wish this technology would go away.
Re:How Optimizely Improved Facebook Ad Retargeting Cost by 83%
by BilalShaikh on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:31PM
(#22940427)
I've been working pretty closely with Optimizely for the last year or so. I would go ahead and say its difficult/impossible to realize the advertised effect of their product. Can't speak to this one directly though.
> After launching the Adaptive Audience campaign, CPA for our technical audience went from $34.47 for general remarketing to $18.80 for the targeted remarketing via adaptive audiences, so an 83% overall improvement for CPA for our technical audience – which is a huge win!
This seems like a misleading way to phrase this. When I hear 83% improvement from $34.47, I expect a 83% ($28.61) drop, ie, 34.47 * (1 - 0.83) = 5.86.
This is more reasonably a (34.47 - 18.80) / 34.47 = 45% drop. Still impressive, but not the same.
Is it really standard to express your improvement in these terms? This would make it trivial to have a >100% drop in cost, which is clearly wrong.
But going from 34.47 to 18.80 is a 45% decrease.
As to your question about whether this is some sort of acceptable alternative way to calculate percentage decrease ... no, this is just a math error.
It's not always great, in my humble opinion, if this results in my being inundated with more ads on the internet. I wish this technology would go away.