The first study states "greater than 45%." This is pure misdirection here.
> Source? Ideally to an independent, real-world study.
There are vast resources available [1]. Evidence suggests it is around 60% at the stack, and ~55% at the system level [2].
> EVs are generally able to get up to 77% efficiency in real-world usage, per the link I posted above. The Tesla Model 3, the most-efficient sedan in 2020 according to the US Dept of Energy [1], gets 141 MPGe.
That's wells-to-wheels figure. You're comparing very different figures. Also, that 141 MPGe figure is just them gaming the fuel economy test [3]. It is not showing up in real world testing.
Using basic physics (which assumes BEVs are 95% at the wheels vs 55% for FCEVs), the peak difference could only be 72%.
> Even hybrids get decently close to hydrogen; the Prius, for example, gets 56 MPG.
The Prius is a much smaller car than the Clarity. Not really a fair comparison.
1. https://www.nrel.gov/hydrogen/fuel-cell-vehicle-evaluation.h...
2. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy19osti/73011.pdf
3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynX21N4H8H0&feature=emb_titl...
The first study in the linked article was conducted in 2010. FWIW, Honda's study (which is the only one I can find a source for that claims 60% tank-to-wheel) was conducted in 2008.
> Fuel cell cars today are at 60% regardless.
Source? Ideally to an independent, real-world study. The EPA MPGe ratings have strongly disagreed with you that hydrogen is comparable to BEVs, as have the studies I've linked, so I'm curious where this 60% real-world claim is coming from.
> This is also hard to dispute, since a 35% efficient fuel cell car cannot approach 68MPGe.
EVs are generally able to get up to 77% efficiency in real-world usage, per the link I posted above. The Tesla Model 3, the most-efficient sedan in 2020 according to the US Dept of Energy [1], gets 141 MPGe.
If we assume the Model 3 is 77% efficient, that leaves the Honda Clarity Fuel Cell (which is rated at 68 MPGe) at approx 37% efficient, since MPGe is strictly a measure of average distance traveled per equivalent unit of energy used [2].
Better than pure gasoline, sure, but it's still pretty far from a BEV. Even hybrids get decently close to hydrogen; the Prius, for example, gets 56 MPG. BEVs absolutely smoke both in terms of efficiency.
1: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/topten.jsp
2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miles_per_gallon_gasoline_equi...