Re:The SF Anti-Mask League of 1919
by dnautics on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:05PM
(#22920771)
It feels like the lesson here is that enforcement with arrests is going to provoke a backlash, whereas convincing people it's good for them is a better strategy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
To me it seems the opposite - persuasion didn't get people to wear masks, and enforcement did.
yes, that's because you're reading it the way the author wants you to. There are other ways to read the same set of facts.
Sure. I just happen to agree with the author's reading and disagree with yours. You're placing a very high weight on relatively mild side effects (a small amount of political dissent and violence), and a low weight on the main effects (a reduction in R0 for the duration of the measures).
One bomb, which would have killed maybe low-single-digit numbers of people if it had worked; and a demonstration which erased the effects of maybe a half a week of compulsory mask-wearing.
Re:The SF Anti-Mask League of 1919
by DSingularity on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:17PM
(#22920830)
Only if you assume people never change. I’m willing to bet people would respond differently today - in times where a record will severely impact your career potential.
This is not okay considering non-violent offense is heavily prosecuted, especially among minority communities. Please consider a more nuanced argument.