News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crimson Contagion by adventured on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:58PM (#22920489)
> We had several months, needed to react with urgency and failed.

That's a rewrite of the actual history that occurred and what people understood along the way.

They had a realistic four to six weeks max to start production of ventilators. A herculean feat in fact. Even less time if you were going to judge it based on understanding the severity and particular intensive-care heavy effects of the virus.

It was not a certainty to the outside world that it was human to human transmissable until the end of January. There was a lot of confusion due to the total lack of access to China and its data.

From February 1st (China's reported numbers begin to spike here) to the point where you understand it's a high global risk, capable of a large scale outbreak that could threaten the US, it's another 1-2 weeks minimum based on the rate of expansion in China's reported numbers and their inability to contain it properly (and better yet, with China you watch what they do more than what they say; during that first and second week of February, China took what seemed like wild action domestically while playing down the danger of SARS-CoV-2 to the rest of the world, including regarding travel restrictions).

Taking the decision to push billions of dollars in spending to jumpstart very early production of PPE and ventilators, is a big decision that you better be right about when you make it. You were going against the behavior of the entire developed world by producing ventilators in February, so now you need to be prepared to look like a paranoid lunatic, along with being called a racist and xenophobe while you restrict travel and close borders.

It's February 7th and you need to coordinate with domestic industry, local governments, international agencies, and companies around the world.

It's February 14th and you've got your first partnership together, they've agreed to produce ventilators.

It's March 7-14th by the time they are able to produce their first ventilator after preparing a factory for it, preparing any necessary design changes to accomodate rapid scale production, and putting together a supply chain that can scale for the hundreds of specific parts in a ventilator.

You need to build a scheme that can produce more ventilators than the present total global annual supply.

It's mid to late April before they have consequential volume of production. Assuming things go well.

Having closely followed all the ventilator efforts around the world, please show me a faster timeline that is realistic. You're only going to beat our present timeline by a matter of weeks, and that's if you aggressively jump out in front of prevailing 'wisdom' at the time.

It's an extraordinary short amount of time to accomplish the ramping up of producing ventilators.

Re:Crimson Contagion by maxerickson on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:15PM (#22920563)
The US intelligence community was watching mid-November.

Singapore started screening incoming travelers Jan 3, based on the pneumonia cluster in Wuhan growing in size.

Xi found out about it and took aggressive measures ~Jan 21.

It was an obvious risk on Jan 3. Maybe not a high probability risk, but obvious enough for a country to make sure they had the first couple of steps of their response at least figured out. Human to human spread was pretty clearly the case when the Chinese government started taking aggressive lockdown measures.

So your timeline is pretty friendly.

And then the focus on ventilators is odd. How about masks and other PPE and testing and so on?

Re:Crimson Contagion by MikeAmelung on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:08PM (#22920793)
> The US intelligence community was watching mid-November.

What? The US intelligence community was watching before the first person was infected? Man, they've gotten a little too good.

Re:Crimson Contagion by wyck on Monday April 20, 2020 @11:44AM (#22924903)
Well China is pushing a narrative that the outbreak started in October at the Wuhan Military world games, you can bet that US intelligance was monitoring this event, and literally competing in the event..over 100 countries participated..things that make you go hmmmm.
Re:Crimson Contagion by maxerickson on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:31PM (#22920884)
Re:Crimson Contagion by MikeAmelung on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:39PM (#22920907)
> "Editor's Note: This story has been updated to reflect comment from the Pentagon."

> "As a matter of practice the National Center for Medical Intelligence does not comment publicly on specific intelligence matters. However, in the interest of transparency during this current public health crisis, we can confirm that media reporting about the existence/release of a National Center for Medical Intelligence Coronavirus-related product/assessment in November of 2019 is not correct. No such NCMI product exists," the statement said.

It doesn't seem likely that they were watching in mid-November when according to

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/13/first-covid-19...

China "may" have retroactively found the first patient to be some guy on Nov. 17. That part could be entirely made up as well, I don't trust anything they say.

Re:Crimson Contagion by zuhayeer on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:06PM (#22920524)
Understood for the production of ventilators. But it's impossible to ignore the other ways we could have prepared: namely redistribution / production of PPE for doctors, and quite simply sheltering in place much much earlier.
Re:Crimson Contagion by adventured on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:21PM (#22920581)
No question there was an epic failure of preparation on normal PPE gear. The US Government should have had a stockpile of N95 masks, as one example, numbering in the multiple hundreds of millions. For something like this, the US really needed a stockpile of a billion plus masks (even if you have massive domestic production capabilities, you obviously can't always rely on that when a pandemic hits).

The big failure was preparation rather than reaction with urgency to produce (that part is exceptionally difficult to do in such a short amount of time, it's setting yourself up for failure, as we've seen in most industrial nations).

Throw into the mix the fact that the world's biggest manufacturer of PPE gear was the center of the pandemic. Meaning they needed all of their own supply and would not be able to export properly so the rest of the world could build up their own supplies. So you're on your own to make your gear (something many nations around the world have had to suffer miserably through; most nations are screwed in this situation, they simply can't make such gear quickly under any scenario). This rapidly broke global supply chains, something never before experienced during the post 1970 high globalization era where supply chains became very complex, more fragile and global.

I'm not arguing that we shouldn't have had more ventilators in stock - we should have. An extra tens of thousands of ventilators in our stockpile would not have been unreasonable. That's another preparation failure spanning decades into the past.

Re:Crimson Contagion by cameldrv on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:58PM (#22920721)
A lot of PPE left the country in January and that could have been prevented. A lot more screening and testing of travelers and symptomatic patients could have been done in February, and we might have been able to contain it in a similar manner to South Korea.
Re:Crimson Contagion by eru on Monday April 20, 2020 @01:29AM (#22921375)
> A lot of PPE left the country in January and that could have been prevented.

For example by legalising 'hoarding' and 'profiteering'. Then some enterprising speculators could have bid for the PPE in the hopes of selling them for higher prices later.

Re:Crimson Contagion by javagram on Monday April 20, 2020 @01:32AM (#22921390)
Your post focuses on ventilators but the government could have ordered additional PPE in January easily.

That’s exactly what Taiwan did for instance - maxed out their own factories and ordered more machines to make PPE in January.

Meanwhile, in mid-February, the largest American factory for making surgical masks was running at less than full capacity as the owner complained to the media that no one would make a long-term contract with him and he and his employees were burned last time he ramped up production for H1N1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/02/15/coronavir...

> “ In an interview, Bowen said he could make 1 million masks a day if he ran his machines around the clock, a huge quantity for his firm but an amount that would barely make a dent in global demand. He’s hesitant, however, to ramp up production at the facility [. . .]“

Re:Crimson Contagion by fatbird on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:18PM (#22920570)
Ventilators are a major shortcoming in the U.S. response to coronavirus only because earlier mitigation efforts (i.e., mass testing) were utterly ignored. South Korea demonstrated clearly that mass testing was the most effective means of isolating carriers, preventing spread, and flattening the curve. Had the U.S. pursued it with the same vigour, the ventilators would never have become a treatment bottleneck.

It would be absurd to ramp up production of ventilators early on because if you're taking action that early, you're taking completely different action.

Re:Crimson Contagion by adventured on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:33PM (#22920639)
What South Korea did was very impressive and that's the reason so few other nations have gotten their result. I don't believe there is any likely scenario where the US could have accomplished what they did.

There is one example of a nation that did what South Korea specifically did, and it's South Korea. They had several attributes unique in combination to South Korea that enabled the speed, cultural response, tech, testing, tracing and manufacturing to come together so well.

Nearly every country on the planet similarly failed to follow precisely what South Korea did. For good reason: they couldn't under any circumstances, realistically, because there are few countries like South Korea.

There are only about a handful of nations that can, for example, rapidly do the testing (tech, scale, manufacturing, distribution, results, reaction) that South Korea pulled off and so quickly. A mere ~4-6 out of 195 nations can do that on the timeline they did it (and that's in a good scenario).

It would have been an extraordinary accomplishment indeed to have such amazing forward-sight to know exactly what was going to happen and to pick the one country to copy the behavior of - and then to move at a lightning speed of manufacturing and cultural behavior the US hasn't seen since the 1940s, based on 20k-40k cases of an infection in China that we didn't know much about.

South Korea has a far more nimble system and society than the US does, for all sorts of reasons. The US is a lumbering goliath, South Korea is a faster start-up. It would be impossible for the US to do what they did, on their timeline, at scale. The best you were likely to get out of the US, is much higher scale testing earlier on, we could have done that.

Re:Crimson Contagion by cameldrv on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:59PM (#22920733)
We absolutely had the tech to get testing up fast. The problem was that the government screwed up making the CDC test and then made every other test illegal. It was pathologically stupid.
Re:Crimson Contagion by mrguyorama on Monday April 20, 2020 @12:38PM (#22925558)
It wasn't about stupidity. A reminder that many aspects of the coronavirus response are being farmed out to brand new companies started and run by the Trump family.
Re:Crimson Contagion by fatbird on Monday April 20, 2020 @12:38AM (#22921132)
I live in British Columbia, Canada, which has, by most measures, had one of the best outcomes after South Korea in terms of 'flattening the curve'. We were unable to do mass testing on the scale of South Korea, but our testing per capita has been among the highest in the world. In addition, we started imposing social distancing measures sooner and more broadly than most.

However it's brought about, reducing transmission and flattening the curve is key. Every country had a variety of means to do so--South Korea's wasn't the only one. The regions that did so early and aggressively were successful at massively reducing the body count in comparison to countries like the U.S. that slow-rolled any and all measures for six weeks--thus, the U.S. will have, at best, 60k deaths instead of the 5k it would have had if it had enacted the measures it did eventually take just two weeks earlier.