News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by mrfusion on Sunday April 19, 2020 @01:06PM (#22917157)
Good points. I’ve always been curious. Why not just plug in A hydrogen car and run the fuel cell in reverse to get a tank of hydrogen?
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by danans on Sunday April 19, 2020 @02:22PM (#22917743)
Doing this would defeat the only advantage hydrogen has, which is rapid fueling. To add to the inconvenience, you'll need to plug in both the electricity, and a hose to your supply of distilled water.

Beyond that, the best case efficiency for such a hydrogen production process in an industrial setting is 80% (using a process which feeds waste heat back into the electrolysis reaction). From the hydrogen back to energy moving the wheels is at most 50% efficient, so a total plug to wheels efficiency of less than 40%. In the real world, it will be far less efficient than that (probably 25% at best), and very expensive to achieve in a practical car for sale, for the same reason that hydrogen fuel cells in cars are expensive today.

That vs the typical plug to wheels efficiency of around 60% in today's electric vehicles.

And such regenerative hydrogen fuel cells do not even exist for automotive applications today.

This paper has several lifecycle efficiency graphs that explain aspects of this in some detail:

https://www.mdpi.com/2032-6653/9/1/3

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by Hypx on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:36PM (#22920359)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03603...

The best case scenario like you described is about 98%. FYI, 80% is already being hit by real world normal electrolysis reactions.

It’s very likely we’re in the same position with fuel cell cars that solar was back in the late-2000s. Arguments that it is “too expensive” are really falling apart, especially considering that green hydrogen is around $2-3/kg today, and that platinum loading has dropped to around 10 grams for a car sized fuel cell.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by danans on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:51PM (#22920700)
> FYI, 80% is already being hit by real world normal electrolysis reactions.

Not in a fuel-cell running in reverse in a car, though, which is what the GP was referring to.

> especially considering that green hydrogen is around $2-3/kg today

More like $3-7 per kg today [1]. And as that article (which is less than 1 month old) points out, producing green hydrogen would require an absolutely massive buildout of renewables, which would better be put to direct use without the conversion penalty to hydrogen. Hydrogen energy storage will still have its niche applications on the margins, but it is unlikely to catch up to the cost and availability advantages of batteries for cars in places where the existing electric grid reaches.

1. https://www.rechargenews.com/transition/a-wake-up-call-on-gr...

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by Hypx on Monday April 20, 2020 @12:31AM (#22921106)
> Not in a fuel-cell running in reverse in a car, though, which is what the GP was referring to.

It would make more sense to have a separate electrolyzer. This way, you can have a tank of hydrogen sitting around that can refuel your car in minutes, not hours. The original scenario is actually a bad idea.

> More like $3-7 per kg today [1]

You're rounding up to $3-7. It specifically refers to $2.50-6.80. Those higher figures aren't really going to stand for long as cheap green hydrogen displaces expensive green hydrogen.

> producing green hydrogen would require an absolutely massive buildout of renewables,

But we are massively building out renewables. In fact, we're building too much. During peak production times, renewable energy is literally just grounded since there is no use for it all.

> Hydrogen energy storage will still have its niche applications on the margins,

Hydrogen can be stored in salt domes in extraordinary quantities.[1] A single cavern can store 150,000 MWh of energy, and one formation in Utah can contain 100 caverns. That's something like 200 million BEVs worth of energy storage! As a niche, it's dominant one, and frankly hydrogen is easily going to be bigger in absolute metrics on that fact alone.

> but it is unlikely to catch up to the cost and availability advantages of batteries for cars in places where the existing electric grid reaches.

This is not a race. Fuel cell technology will still advance regardless of what happens of battery powered cars. Furthermore, nothing is close to the internal combustion engine in terms of marketshare. If it were a race, ICEVs are way ahead and neither BEVs nor FCEVs are anywhere close to winning.

1. https://www.forbes.com/sites/mitsubishiheavyindustries/2020/...

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by danans on Monday April 20, 2020 @01:23PM (#22926043)
> It would make more sense to have a separate electrolyzer.

A separate electrolyser and hydrogen storage at the household level just to fill up your car? It's doubtful that will make financial sense anytime in the near future, vs a plug.

> It specifically refers to $2.50-6.80.

You quoted $2-3 - in whole dollars - which are undoubtedly rounded figured themselves. How else would express $2.50-6.80 in whole dollars than $3-7?

> But we are massively building out renewables.

Not nearly enough to power ground transportation on green hydrogen, which was the point of the article I linked. On top of that, the tank-to-wheels efficiency of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles is 1/2 that of BEVs, which implies double the renewable electricity needed for green hydrogen vs directly using electricity in BEVs. It's better to keep ground transport as efficient as possible by using BEVs, and use the remaining electricity to synthesize fuels for applications like aviation that don't lend themselves to batteries due to weight constraints.

> A single cavern can store 150,000 MWh of energy, and one formation in Utah can contain 100 caverns.

There's a lot of "can" in that, similar to initiatives pushing carbon-capture from coal plants. I applaud it if it eventually works, but that article is a paid marketing release (note the "Mitsubishi Heavy Industries BRANDVOICE| Paid Program" at the top).

> This is not a race. Fuel cell technology will still advance regardless of what happens of battery powered cars

It is a race to which tech has a market viable product for cleanly fueled road transportation. Battery tech isn't sitting still either, especially on the rapid charging and range front. It's totally possible that hydrogen tech will come through with a series of breakthroughs that mitigate its current issues with cost, lack of distribution infra, but projections like the one in the article I shared put that out 10-20 years, and predicting anything past 10 years is a crapshoot anyways.

> If it were a race, ICEVs are way ahead and neither BEVs nor FCEVs are anywhere close to winning.

It's a race for the transportation tech of the future. Obviously ICEs are the majority of vehicles now, but that's hardly interesting to the debate about FCEVs vs BEVs, except in the matter of how much the gap between either of the new technologies and ICEs closes on the consumer price level.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by Hypx on Monday April 20, 2020 @02:51PM (#22927031)
> A separate electrolyser and hydrogen storage at the household level just to fill up your car? It's doubtful that will make financial sense anytime in the near future, vs a plug.

It will likely be akin to those people who put solar panels on their roofs and have backup power storage. Probably not for everyone, but for some groups of people it could make sense for them.

> Not nearly enough to power ground transportation on green hydrogen, which was the point of the article I linked. On top of that, the tank-to-wheels efficiency of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles is 1/2 that of BEVs, which implies double the renewable electricity needed for green hydrogen vs directly using electricity in BEVs. It's better to keep ground transport as efficient as possible by using BEVs, and use the remaining electricity to synthesize fuels for applications like aviation that don't lend themselves to batteries due to weight constraints.

If we’re already hitting majority renewable energy at their on peak on the grid, then we’re already on the verge of making too much. There are still huge solar and winds projects still being built, so it’s a guarantee we’ll make too much. Furthermore, we need backup energy storage to smooth out the intermittency. This is already being developed on using hydrogen.

Finally, I do hope you understand what synfuels are. They’re basically made from H2 and CO2, and having a huge H2 economy is a prerequisite to making them.

> There's a lot of "can" in that, similar to initiatives pushing carbon-capture from coal plants. I applaud it if it eventually works, but that article is a paid marketing release (note the "Mitsubishi Heavy Industries BRANDVOICE| Paid Program" at the top).

We were already storing hydrogen in this way for decades. This is a definite certainty that it can work. The question is whether there will be enough renewable hydrogen to fill the facility, not that it can’t work.

> It is a race to which tech has a market viable product for cleanly fueled road transportation. Battery tech isn't sitting still either, especially on the rapid charging and range front. It's totally possible that hydrogen tech will come through with a series of breakthroughs that mitigate its current issues with cost, lack of distribution infra, but projections like the one in the article I shared put that out 10-20 years, and predicting anything past 10 years is a crapshoot anyways.

> It's a race for the transportation tech of the future. Obviously ICEs are the majority of vehicles now, but that's hardly interesting to the debate about FCEVs vs BEVs, except in the matter of how much the gap between either of the new technologies and ICEs closes on the consumer price level.

The point being that BEVs can succeed, and still be displaced when FCEVs reaches a certain point. Moreover, neither are in any position to displace ICEVs yet. The most economical car you can by is some kind of ICEVs, especially if it is a hybrid of some sort.

I want to add that there are many sectors, such as large trucks, trains, ships, etc., that we are quite certain that batteries will never make sense in all likelihood. This pretty much requires we go the hydrogen route on them. That also makes refusing to invest in hydrogen equivalent to just giving up on reducing GHG in those sectors. So fuel cell technology is a necessary investment and not really optional.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by mrpopo on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:32PM (#22920632)
> so a total plug to wheels efficiency of less than 40%. In the real world, it will be far less efficient than that (probably 25% at best).

> That vs the typical plug to wheels efficiency of around 60% in today's electric vehicles.

1) Just to add a point of comparison, current ICE engines have an efficiency of around 25-35%, so while 25% sounds bad, that's the technology we've been putting up with for a century. But obviously, new technologies ought to be more efficient.

2) Speaking of efficiency, here we are talking about plug-to-wheel efficiencies. The true useful efficiency of a car is the ability to move you to your destination.

So adding in the "weight efficiency" of 5-10%, given a 1-2t car and a 100kg charge (based on average 1.5 people occupancy in a car), the efficiency drops to ~1% for ICE/hydrogen cars and ~3% for electric cars.

Please consider using lighter cars, a lot more gains can be achieved that way.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by pmorici on Sunday April 19, 2020 @01:46PM (#22917434)
The only reason that Hydrogen powered cars are even still discussed over battery electric is that 95% of industrial hydrogen is produced from fossil fuels. In other words the people pushing it are probably protecting their oil and gas interests. They aren't going to put money into research to cut themselves out of the loop.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by Hypx on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:38PM (#22920382)
But nobody is suggesting that industrial hydrogen will be natural gas based forever. Furthermore, we must have green hydrogen for steel and ammonia production. So this is a “must solve” problem no matter what.

This is basically the same kind of argument that BEVs are “secretly powered by coal.” These are backwards looking statements that are going to be wrong in the near future.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by clouddrover on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:05PM (#22920516)
> In other words the people pushing it are probably protecting their oil and gas interests.

Shell builds EV charging stations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nst2RGtgzfk

BP builds EV charging stations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaSRn6hYOwc

Petro-Canada builds EV charging stations: https://www.petro-canada.ca/en/personal/fuel/canadas-electri...

They're in the energy business. They don't really care what form it takes.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by kube-system on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:36PM (#22920899)
It is advantageous to get a foot hold in competitive markets, for sure.... but these actions are also heavily motivated by ulterior motives: tax credits, PR/marketing, lobbying, undermining competitive threats, etc.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by clouddrover on Monday April 20, 2020 @01:45AM (#22921457)
So just like every big business in every industry.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by blibble on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:33PM (#22920888)
in a world where everyone has a charger at home and at work there's little to no need for Shell and BP

hence their push for hydrogen, where everything remains essentially the same (and they keep their vertically integrated business)

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by clouddrover on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:42PM (#22920914)
Look, Shell is the third largest company in the world. They have many, many business interests. The idea that more EVs means Shell goes broke is pure fantasy.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by blibble on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:50PM (#22920949)
what sort of argument is that?

large companies disappear all the time, or are swallowed by by others that outcompete them

"9 of every 10 Fortune 500 companies in 1955 are gone": https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/fortune-500-firms-1955-v-2017...

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by tomhoward on Monday April 20, 2020 @01:42AM (#22921432)
That 9/10 figure is misleading, if you browse the list here: https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune500_archive/f...

Many more than 1/10 of those names are still dominant companies/brands, but some have gone through mergers or restructures, meaning the 1955 entity no longer exists but the business lives on and remains very strong.

BP and Shell are on that 1955 list, and are obviously still very strong companies.

According to the Lindy effect [1], the longer a company has existed, the longer it is likely to continue to exist.

Both BP and Shell have long been diversified companies (even in the 1950s, Shell had vast business activities outside of petroleum), and have long been investing heavily in various forms of alternative energy.

They're not likely to disappear in any foreseeable timeframe.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by gok on Sunday April 19, 2020 @06:13PM (#22919229)
One issue is that you need a source of water. Another is that electrolysis is only around 70% efficient, whereas (say) lithium ion battery charging is more like 95% efficient.