Re:Why editorial illustrations look so similar these days (2...
by satvikpendem on Saturday April 18, 2020 @10:51AM
(#22908143)
Regarding 1, skeumorphism looks fake, because it is, since we're not using physical controls on a digital device anymore, so the metaphors are not as useful. Vector art, as you say, is less physical but conforms to digital devices better. Now neumorphism is up and coming, but I think it still looks bad, for the same reasons as skeumorphism.
Re:Why editorial illustrations look so similar these days (2...
by pcurve on Saturday April 18, 2020 @11:12AM
(#22908266)
2) is spot on.
This type of style is illustration equivalent of gradient and drop shadow. Anybody can use them to make things look decent without much skill.
Also, for the most part, people who are paying these illustrators do not have trained background to understand the extra cost associated with higher effort work.
Re:Why editorial illustrations look so similar these days (2...
by ric2b on Saturday April 18, 2020 @10:32AM
(#22908026)
Yeah, I see it as very similar to what we see with programming languages. Technically these tools offer infinite flexibility and let you do anything, but what you'll see more often is what the tools makes easy, what they encourage.
But besides the flat aesthetic having started on phones over the past decade-plus, I think there are two key factors the article hints at but doesn't really address directly.
1) If you're illustrating on your computer, there's something more inherently (although subjectively) "honest" about flat design -- it looks like computer vector shapes. Using brushes in Photoshop/Procreate is a throwback, "fake", simulated. If digital is the medium, then basically either pixel art or vector art are the two "most authentic" expressions of that medium.
2) Economically, shapes in Illustrator/etc. are infinitely easier to tweak. If the editor wants you to adjust your image, you might be able to spend just 10 minutes making the changes, rather than 6 hours drawing/painting up a totally new version. (Yes I know painting programs can support layers and other fancy things to help, but it's still going to be harder.)
Also, because flat art requires a good eye but very little learned "technical" technique (as opposed to, say, watercolor or oil painting), a lot more people can do it (just keep tweaking the shapes until it looks right), and it's very easy to achieve consistency across images, even if made by totally different people.