Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by m0zg on Saturday April 18, 2020 @04:48AM
(#22906277)
It's remarkable how a non-randomized study of Hydroxychloroquine is anathema, yet a non-randomized study of Remdesivir that's paid for by its manufacturer and written up by that manufacturer's employee is not. Hmm, I wonder why that is. To top it off, it might actually have the same QT prolongation issues, because some other antivirals have them.
That said, politics aside, I hope it works far beyond our wildest expectations so fewer people die.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by throwaway_pdp09 on Saturday April 18, 2020 @05:29AM
(#22906438)
I'd like to know if there was any evidence or indication of the value of HQNN before a certain president started spouting it. AFAIK the only reason we're talking about it is because he did. If that's so then there's no reason to pick HQNN as being special over any other drug. I suppose there's that very dodgy french study, perhaps that's what started it all off.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by m0zg on Saturday April 18, 2020 @05:31AM
(#22906448)
Basically exactly the same kind of "evidence" as what we have now for remdesivir. Some patients got better while on it, but because there was no control arm we don't know whether they'd do worse (or better) without the drug.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by gridlockd on Saturday April 18, 2020 @07:03AM
(#22906868)
Virologists generally agree that it is a plausible drug to treat COVID-19, but will quickly point out that efficacy is unproven and we need to wait for better studies.
Also, a couple of doctors who are regarded as "cranks" started applying it early in the disease and presumably had success with. Trump picked up on that, so now a lot of people have reason to hate on it. Trump poisoned the well.
No "proper" doctor is going to administer a dangerous drug to a non-critical patient to prevent what might turn out to be a harmless course of the diseases. However, that also means if these drugs work, but only in the early stages, then we won't find out any time soon.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by Fjolsvith on Saturday April 18, 2020 @09:07AM
(#22907438)
> No "proper" doctor is going to administer a dangerous drug to a non-critical patient to prevent what might turn out to be a harmless course of the diseases.
This "dangerous" drug has been used in medicine for 60 years for probably more than a billion or two people. I'm sure that a "proper" doctor faced with a dying patient that is unresponsive to everything else is going to offer this drug. Its a good thing that congress approved the Right To Try law.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by panpanna on Saturday April 18, 2020 @10:40AM
(#22908071)
> This "dangerous" drug has been used in medicine for 60 years
Note that the doses required here are MUCH higher (one European hospital tried 1000mg doses) which is toxic. It can result in blindness, heart failure and other issues.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by m0zg on Saturday April 18, 2020 @10:44PM
(#22913050)
Retinal damage is not an issue unless you take it for years. Heart failure is not an issue in a hospital because it's not sudden, so all treatment protocols specify that patients are monitored for QT prolongation. Moreover if you don't get it right away, you're unlikely to get it at all. "Other issues" in this case are mostly nausea and diarrhea. I don't know about you, but I'd rather shit myself than die.
That's why I wrote non-critical patients. There are doctors administering it in a prophylactic fashion, supposedly with success. That's highly controversial.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by alimw on Saturday April 18, 2020 @10:28AM
(#22907995)
Are there countries in which a significant fraction of the population takes it on a regular basis? Presumably these are the same places in which an actually large fraction of the population has had malaria and in which there is some naturally evolved resistance to it, so you'd have to control for that...
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by lern_too_spel on Saturday April 18, 2020 @12:26PM
(#22908775)
There aren't any. Most regions with high risk of malaria (like India) have malarias that have chloroquine resistance, and the only places without chloroquine resistant malaria are in Central America and the Caribbean. Hydroxychloroquine is even less effective than chloroquine on those chloroquine resistant malarias. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12837731/
Most Indians, for example, don't take any antimalarials until they actually have malaria.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by panpanna on Saturday April 18, 2020 @05:27AM
(#22906426)
Why does this have to be political?
One drug has turned out to be mostly ineffective and in some cases dangerous, people have died. Another one seems to work okay-ish in a huge coordinated experiment.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by teefcj on Saturday April 18, 2020 @08:54AM
(#22907370)
It's stabilized under the current shelter in place regime, which will almost certainly have to be lifted at least partially for economic-political reasons.
When that happens my guess is there will be new waves of illness.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by jhayward on Saturday April 18, 2020 @01:31PM
(#22909355)
I think this makes the mistake of thinking there is such a thing as a global infection rate. There are instead a couple of hundred separate epidemics, each with its own R0 and trajectory.
It’s also dangerously wrong, but human nature, to look at the current state of epidemics and project their future state. Epidemics that have been suppressed rather than extinguished resemble unstable explosives. Just because they’re sitting there nicely today doesn’t mean they won’t explode 3 seconds from now.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by gridlockd on Saturday April 18, 2020 @05:04PM
(#22911089)
There is a global average infection rate. Of course it's just an average, but is representative of the growth of global cases. Of course you can arbitrarily divide this down from hundreds of epidemics to thousands of outbreaks, but we're talking about the global supply of the drug.
> It’s also dangerously wrong, but human nature, to look at the current state of epidemics and project their future state.
I'm sorry, but in the real world you have to make predictions in order to make decisions. If you never make predictions you can always be right, but then you'll always be useless.
> Epidemics that have been suppressed rather than extinguished resemble unstable explosives. Just because they’re sitting there nicely today doesn’t mean they won’t explode 3 seconds from now.
An "explosion" in that sense will still take weeks to become critical, giving you time to react, assuming you have testing and tracing capacity.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by jhayward on Sunday April 19, 2020 @07:25PM
(#22919662)
> I'm sorry, but in the real world you have to make predictions in order to make decisions.
I'll overlook the implication that I don't live in the 'real world'. What the statement means is that just because you're fine today you can ease up, because you really don't like the shutdown. You're still standing in an explosives factory, and now propose to shoot off bottle rockets just because nothing bad has happened today.
In the real world, you look at conditions as they are. In this case, those conditions are that the virus is still epidemic and there are none of the preconditions necessary to contain it present in the US, at least, and also in most of Europe.
> assuming you have testing and tracing capacity
Where is it that you are describing, since you are 'in the real world'?
Here in the US there is no where that I am aware of that has sufficient testing and tracing capacity to deal with a 3-week old exponential outbreak.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by cheriot on Saturday April 18, 2020 @08:38PM
(#22912399)
> There is a global average infection rate. Of course it's just an average, but is representative of the growth of global cases
Flattening the curve in NYC and Lombardy does not change the trajectory of Brazil and every other developing country. Even India’s fast response is less likely to work than a rich country’s shelter in place. As long as there is exponential spread out there it will keep showing up wherever you call home.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by cheriot on Saturday April 18, 2020 @12:23PM
(#22908750)
The places that are growing are too early in the curve to move that needle. The developing world got it first because people travel more, but the virus has reached poor countries and they won't have as many options.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by prox on Saturday April 18, 2020 @04:25AM
(#22906189)
Like the article says, there have been some hopeful anecdotes, but that is a long way from an effective cure and rigorous testing phase. Aka to early to tell.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by kmlevitt on Saturday April 18, 2020 @04:58AM
(#22906305)
Actually no we wouldn’t, because real clinical trials with thousands of subjects take a long time to wrap up, even when researchers are working at breakneck speed.
FWIW The anecdotal evidence from doctors and patients who have managed to get a hold of some of it has been very good so far.
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by confiscate on Sunday April 19, 2020 @04:15AM
(#22914359)
yes but, if in a trial, if one arm performs substantially different than the control arm (e.g. 50% or even 100% lower death rate), the large difference between arms can lead to investigators ending the trial early
ironically, this happened in a previous 2019 trial of Remdemsivir, for a different virus, Ebola
in that trial, 4 drugs for Ebola were tested, including Remdemsivir. 2 non-Remdemsivir drugs succeeded substantially--the large difference between those drugs and Remdemsivir, was enough to cause the investigator to end the trial early and drop Remdemsivir
ironically, the investigator for that trial was none-other-than Dr. Fauci. Maybe that's why he hasn't mentioned Remdemsivir much on TV these days, based on his past professional disappointing experience with Remdemsivir
also, double ironically, Remdemsivir was initially designed to treat Ebola virus, not for flu or coronavirus type viruses. The fact that after the Ebola trial, Remdemsivir was declared not that effective for Ebola (the very virus Remdemsivir was created for), means there is even less of a chance Remdemsivir will prove to be effective for Covid-19 in the current trials
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by confiscate on Sunday April 19, 2020 @04:48AM
(#22914478)
as an extreme example
if Remdemsivir cures 100% of all Covid-19 cases, halfway through the trial, they would have enough data to show a net positive benefit. They don't need to finish the whole trial to declare Remdemsivir useful
the fact that they are running the whole trial to finish, most likely means the effect of Remdemsivir is not too noticeable. They need more data to get to statistical significance. Hence, they want the trial to run to original planned finish date.
my guess is
Remdemsivir probably has some positive effect. Say, 10% lower death rate if used during 1st few days of infection. Still great, much much better than our current situation of nothing. It would not cure Covid completely, but it would help substantially, especially in large populations of infected
Re:Is remdesivir the drug that can kill the coronavirus?
by roenxi on Saturday April 18, 2020 @05:11AM
(#22906363)
Plus, killing off the virus isn't necessarily going to be equivalent to observed outcomes. It is easy to imagine someone having no viruses but their lungs aren't working properly because of damage done so they are still sick.
So even a perfectly efficacious drug would still not necessarily be an obvious miracle cure, depending on how the disease progression works.
This is a good time to wait for clinical trials to finish.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22783363
That said, politics aside, I hope it works far beyond our wildest expectations so fewer people die.
Also, a couple of doctors who are regarded as "cranks" started applying it early in the disease and presumably had success with. Trump picked up on that, so now a lot of people have reason to hate on it. Trump poisoned the well.
No "proper" doctor is going to administer a dangerous drug to a non-critical patient to prevent what might turn out to be a harmless course of the diseases. However, that also means if these drugs work, but only in the early stages, then we won't find out any time soon.
This "dangerous" drug has been used in medicine for 60 years for probably more than a billion or two people. I'm sure that a "proper" doctor faced with a dying patient that is unresponsive to everything else is going to offer this drug. Its a good thing that congress approved the Right To Try law.
Note that the doses required here are MUCH higher (one European hospital tried 1000mg doses) which is toxic. It can result in blindness, heart failure and other issues.
https://www.nicematin.com/sante/coronavirus-nous-avons-deja-...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22797185
That's why I wrote non-critical patients. There are doctors administering it in a prophylactic fashion, supposedly with success. That's highly controversial.
That's a few orders of magnitude off.
Most Indians, for example, don't take any antimalarials until they actually have malaria.
One drug has turned out to be mostly ineffective and in some cases dangerous, people have died. Another one seems to work okay-ish in a huge coordinated experiment.
I don't see where politics come into this.
> people have died
Citation needed. And no, aquarium cleaner dude is not what I mean by "citation".
Even without that, an unbiased person would at the very least be equally sceptical to both.
Unless you know someone who recovered after taking the drug.
The official reports will be available in 2 weeks.
They had called the family in to say goodbyes because the guy wasn't supposed to make it through the night. I'd say the drug saved his life.
Short answer, because Politicians publicly pushed Hydroxychloroquine. You should know that.
> the firm has set an “ambitious goal” of producing more than 500,000 treatment courses by October, and 1m by the end of the year
So no. Even if this is a cure, the pandemic gets worse before it gets better.
If 80% of those infected do not need treatment at all, that amount of courses may well be sufficient, or close to it.
When that happens my guess is there will be new waves of illness.
It’s also dangerously wrong, but human nature, to look at the current state of epidemics and project their future state. Epidemics that have been suppressed rather than extinguished resemble unstable explosives. Just because they’re sitting there nicely today doesn’t mean they won’t explode 3 seconds from now.
> It’s also dangerously wrong, but human nature, to look at the current state of epidemics and project their future state.
I'm sorry, but in the real world you have to make predictions in order to make decisions. If you never make predictions you can always be right, but then you'll always be useless.
> Epidemics that have been suppressed rather than extinguished resemble unstable explosives. Just because they’re sitting there nicely today doesn’t mean they won’t explode 3 seconds from now.
An "explosion" in that sense will still take weeks to become critical, giving you time to react, assuming you have testing and tracing capacity.
I'll overlook the implication that I don't live in the 'real world'. What the statement means is that just because you're fine today you can ease up, because you really don't like the shutdown. You're still standing in an explosives factory, and now propose to shoot off bottle rockets just because nothing bad has happened today.
In the real world, you look at conditions as they are. In this case, those conditions are that the virus is still epidemic and there are none of the preconditions necessary to contain it present in the US, at least, and also in most of Europe.
> assuming you have testing and tracing capacity
Where is it that you are describing, since you are 'in the real world'?
Here in the US there is no where that I am aware of that has sufficient testing and tracing capacity to deal with a 3-week old exponential outbreak.
Flattening the curve in NYC and Lombardy does not change the trajectory of Brazil and every other developing country. Even India’s fast response is less likely to work than a rich country’s shelter in place. As long as there is exponential spread out there it will keep showing up wherever you call home.
FWIW The anecdotal evidence from doctors and patients who have managed to get a hold of some of it has been very good so far.
ironically, this happened in a previous 2019 trial of Remdemsivir, for a different virus, Ebola
in that trial, 4 drugs for Ebola were tested, including Remdemsivir. 2 non-Remdemsivir drugs succeeded substantially--the large difference between those drugs and Remdemsivir, was enough to cause the investigator to end the trial early and drop Remdemsivir
ironically, the investigator for that trial was none-other-than Dr. Fauci. Maybe that's why he hasn't mentioned Remdemsivir much on TV these days, based on his past professional disappointing experience with Remdemsivir
also, double ironically, Remdemsivir was initially designed to treat Ebola virus, not for flu or coronavirus type viruses. The fact that after the Ebola trial, Remdemsivir was declared not that effective for Ebola (the very virus Remdemsivir was created for), means there is even less of a chance Remdemsivir will prove to be effective for Covid-19 in the current trials
https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/08/finally-some-good-ne...
if Remdemsivir cures 100% of all Covid-19 cases, halfway through the trial, they would have enough data to show a net positive benefit. They don't need to finish the whole trial to declare Remdemsivir useful
the fact that they are running the whole trial to finish, most likely means the effect of Remdemsivir is not too noticeable. They need more data to get to statistical significance. Hence, they want the trial to run to original planned finish date.
my guess is
Remdemsivir probably has some positive effect. Say, 10% lower death rate if used during 1st few days of infection. Still great, much much better than our current situation of nothing. It would not cure Covid completely, but it would help substantially, especially in large populations of infected
So even a perfectly efficacious drug would still not necessarily be an obvious miracle cure, depending on how the disease progression works.
This is a good time to wait for clinical trials to finish.