News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Allows Sony to Unmask Anyone Who Visited GeoHot Site by fingerprinter on Friday March 04, 2011 @07:14PM (#2290362)
I think in all those cases you mentioned it would be usage restrictions rather than actually being able to change the physical object you bought. And it would be the government saying you can't do something, not BMW or Colt handguns.

Again, INAL, but I thought you could modify a semi-auto and saw off the barrel as long as they were used at the shooting range (for instance...probably a state by state law as well).

And I'm fairly certain you can bypass the emission on the car to modify to make it a track car, for instance, or make it farm equipment. Again, not really up on the law, more anecdotes I've seen in my personal life.

Re:Judge Allows Sony to Unmask Anyone Who Visited GeoHot Site by chris_j on Saturday March 05, 2011 @02:20AM (#2291011)
> And it would be the government saying you can't do something, not BMW or Colt handguns.

I think this is a key point. Is it the government telling you that you can't do something (that is against the law) or a company using the law to prevent you doing something that they don't want you to do. I would guess that the former would be governed by criminal law and the latter by civil law - please correct me if I am wrong.

In this case, it is Sony using the law to try to prevent people learning how to root their PS3s and doing so through civil courts.

Re:Judge Allows Sony to Unmask Anyone Who Visited GeoHot Site by CWuestefeld on Friday March 04, 2011 @10:20PM (#2290734)
I thought you could modify a semi-auto and saw off the barrel as long as they were used at the shooting range (for instance...probably a state by state law as well

Nope, it's a federal law that prohibits you from possessing a short-barreled shotgun or a full-auto anything. This is since the National Firearms Act of 1934. Selling such a shotgun (after being goaded into it and entrapped by a ATF agent) was what precipitated the Ruby Ridge massacre.

In fact -- and you'd think this would fall foul of the 1st Amendment -- it's illegal to distribute a pamphlet that tells someone how to convert their rifle to full auto.

Re:Judge Allows Sony to Unmask Anyone Who Visited GeoHot Site by megaframe on Friday March 04, 2011 @08:05PM (#2290475)
I agree... usage issue: another example is modify a phone so it transmits at non-standard frequencies I'm in my right to do it. If I'm at home or a non-public place that's shielded I can do what I want, but the public airways outside are under FCC regulation and then I'm breaking the law not for doing the modification but for using it in regulated space. It's the same way a companies tests out development phones and transmitters before getting a licence.