Labor isn't the limiting factor. You need machines, raw materials, supply chains.
There isn't an AWS for N95 mask manufacturing.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/pdx3dplab/ https://team2471.org/ https://pdxhackerspace.org/
This is just in the Portland area. I assume there are similar efforts around the country and around the world.
Ideally this stuff should be made in factories rather than hundreds of bespoke 3d printers operated by volunteers, but if the need and motivation is there, a lot can be accomplished. Maybe it's not enough, but it's a lot more than nothing. And the longer this goes on, the more efficient the organization and manufacturing gets.
Normally the regular supply chain would handle all this, but if the supply chain is broken by hoarding behavior or the wrong kinds of active government intervention, the alternative is to bypass the usual market and use whatever local workforce volunteers or can be hired to make what's needed directly for the institutions in need.
You need a lot of capital for a melt-blown fabric facility, and some specialized engineers. China and Taiwan managed to build new facilities of huge size very quickly - it can be done, but apparently much harder for the large American conglomerates to get off the ground as quickly. https://www.wfuv.org/content/covid-19-has-caused-shortage-fa...
If you can get >$10 million together, and a very dedicated and specialized team of engineers, plant operators, machinists, and businesspeople - you might be able to finish your factory before 3M's Rhode Island and Arizona plants, if you start right now. But you won't do it in a distributed way with a bunch of people with 3D printers.
However, it seems there's evidence that non N95 masks have some efficacy. Just regular old cotton clothing cloth. You could start an MLM/Amway/Mary-Kay/Avon/Vemma/Younique style thing to get out-of-work people to make these at home and sell them to friends and family.
Sinopec decided on Feb 24 to built a melt-blown fabric plant https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9lchhBE7cE. It was operating on March 6. It took them 10-12 days to build, from scratch, a facility to produce 1.2 million N95 masks per day. One of my links above shows another facility built in 11+ days making 200,000 N95 masks per day.
At the start of the outbreak, Taiwan could product 100,000 N95 masks per day, but have built over 60 production lines, and now make enough melt blown fabric to product over 20 million N95 masks per day. Notably, Taiwan had a HUGE stockpile of masks, so even though making 100,000 masks per day wasn't enough for their population, they had enough in storage to last them while they built up their capacity. Now they make enough to send tons of masks the the USA every week.
USA (3M) decided to build melt-blown fabric facilities around March 23: https://www.powderbulksolids.com/news/Honeywell-Expands-N95-... and to a much smaller capacity. And none of the new lines in the USA are up and running yet. "Before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, 3M was manufacturing about 50 million masks per month" ... "In its continuing effort to help meet demand, 3M says it is working to double its global N95 mask production numbers once again to 200 million units monthly." But they think that will take another YEAR to accomplish. Only 35 million N95 masks are currently made in the USA, by 3M or others. https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/n95-mask-production-wont-mee...
Ideally, each citizen would have a new N95 mask for every day. We'll get to 1 mask per citizen per month, sometime around a year from now.
We marvel sometimes at how quickly China raises cities from the dust seemingly out of nowhere in short time frames. In this very thread are reports of Chinese companies building entire factories to manufacture N95 masks in weeks, including brand new factories for the difficult melt-blown fabric material.
The US doesn't lack the ability, it lacks the will and the vision. The alternative sentiment to what I'm saying is "It's too hard, it will take too long and China can do it better so let's all wait it out at home doing nothing until they catch up enough to get us what we need". Why do people believe this? Where are the leaders saying anything else?
It's funny because this was a U.S. conservative talking point going back as long as I can remember (for me that's the mid/late 90s). There's even an episode of The Office (U.S.) where this point of view is lampooned (Oscar to Michael: "Wouldn't you say that the services sector is much more relevant than manufacturing?"). Never thought I'd see it expressed openly on HN, and with upvotes!
They should not be just asking for help, they should lead, and command the emergency respone.
With the state of emergency declared, they have full authority to order businesses to make supplies, or requisition manufacturing facilities for that.
In short what the world needs is plans on how to make n95 mask making machines. There are plenty of manufacturers who can take those plans and build the machines in a few weeks (I'm guessing on time line but it seems reasonable) from there we can make as many masks as we have raw materials for.
But it's very much possible to expand NWF production at existing facilities many-times-fold.
But even that is not really needed. There are factories in China with piles of NWF that has nowhere to go because of the export ban.
So, it's really a non-issue... if global community could've functioned even on the level how it did 20 years ago.
The world community is no more... and the global cooperation went away along with it
The West had 20 years to do something about this, but it didn't.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9lchhBE7cE https://wfuv.org/content/covid-19-has-caused-shortage-face-m...
Where are you seeing reports on piles of NWF in China? I'd be very interested in this. Seems the masks/filters are pretty easy to make once you have the NWF
Chinese can probably make their own machinery eventually, but we still talk about months
Of course the traditional way to build these machines is more efficient.
If it was reasonable, why hasn’t it happened? Seems like it’s either not possible, or not worth it at whatever price points the masks would sell at, which is basically the same thing.
NPR wrote a good piece about this, if my memory serves me right. I apologise for the lack of sources.
Labor isn't the only limiting factor:
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/03/16/8149292...:
> COVID-19 Has Caused A Shortage Of Face Masks. But They're Surprisingly Hard To Make
> ...
> Both the masks made for medical personnel and for consumer purchase require a once-obscure material called melt-blown fabric. It's an extremely fine mesh of synthetic polymer fibers that forms the critical inner filtration layer of a mask, allowing the wearer to breath while reducing the inflow of possible infectious particles...
> And there's now a global shortage of melt-blown fabric due to the increased demand for masks — and the difficulty in producing this material.
Maybe it will take months/years to go from zero to production quantity/quality no matter how hard we try or how well we organize. And maybe by the time that production capacity is active the market will be flooded by PPE from China (let's hope). Yet I would still rather be over-prepared and with people actively productive compared to behind the ball with people sat at home.
Maybe I'm just tired of the government telling us to be patient while we continue to hear reports like this. I want someone to tell us how to be proactive.
There are many other tutorials online from various sources which use different machines (sewing machine, 3d printers, etc), so people can improvise based on what they have.
The PDF shows detailed price breakdown for materials of ~$5/mask and estimates 10 minutes per mask, since of course it's diy, there's a lot of warning labels, but it's better than nothing. If people can produce ~40 masks per day using basic tools, this can scale based on the availability of raw materials and tools.
Who is left, between the federal and state governments, except private companies? Some of them are doing things to acquire or manufacture PPE but it's a piecemeal effort. Apple and Tesla come to mind as companies not traditionally in the medical space who are trying to help.
The only way this will work on a nationwide scale is if the federal government coordinates it. Leaving it to the states is problematic because some states won't try to do it, and some can't afford to do it without federal money even if they wanted to. That's only going to get worse as unemployment claims use up all the money the states have left.
Your comment made me think of a wild and impractical idea. Airbnb, Uber, Lyft, Etsy and others unlocked a gig economy in specific industries. Is there any possibility to do the same with PPE?
Beyond volunteer sewing efforts that are already happening and do not produce medical-grade PPE, the answer is no.
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/watchdog/2020/04/03/if-you-i...
> ...during an outbreak like this, everybody wants to be [an American mask/respirator maker's] customer. But as soon as an outbreak subsides, his customers dump him and run back to China. The reason? His masks may cost a dime each, but a made-in-China mask might go for two cents.
> “Last time he geared up and went three shifts a day working his tail off,” the mayor recalled. “As soon as the issue died, he didn’t have any sales. He had to pay unemployment for all these people, and he had to gear down.”
Also, why would you think anti-gouging laws would be the problem? The only thing raising prices would do is send PPE towards people with money who may or may not have actual need. No one sensible is going to ramp up extra capacity or create stockpiles of perishable goods with the idea that they'd be able to gouge during infrequent, unpredictable crises. The only people that price gouging helps are the parasitic middlemen who make a profit engaging in it, and the fools with money to burn who can't demonstrate priority need.
Of course it is unlikely someone would take the risk, but gouging laws make it impossible.
For every $10 of masks some wannabe gouger was motivated to buy and store in their closest for years, a professional gouger will buy $10,000 worth the day the crisis starts and help hasten the arrival of empty shelves and shortages. Then he'll turn around and ask those who truly need them for $100,000. If he can't sell all his inventory at his markup, he'll just dump the remainder after it's no longer needed for the crisis at the regular market price.
Nothing is exempt from market forces. Masks are more valuable now than they used to be, that's just a fact. If you try and hide that fact, you will prolong the shortage and cause more harm than good. If you don't like the idea of the government having to pay more to procure this essential commodity in this time of sudden shortage, the people you should be annoyed with are the ones who depleted the national PPE stockpile in time of plenty, when it existed for this very reason. Don't shoot the messenger.
You might also enjoy wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_efficiency#Mainstream...
The "mainstream views" section suggests that market economies are believed to be closer to efficient than other known alternatives. The mainstream only recommends macroeconomic type interventions to counteract the economic cycle. Macroeconomic interventions are monetary policy, not price fixing, confiscation, etc.
Or how about the wikipedia on price gouging: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_gouging#Opposition_to_la...
In a survey of economists, only 8% supported legislation against price gouging. 51% were against. The economists opposing the proposal argued that such legislation would lead to a misallocation of resources and lead to lower supply and greater scarcity of the resources, or argued that the proposal in question was vague.
Or how about the wikipedia on economic planning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_economy#Advantages_of_...
The advantages show the Soviet Union industrializing... while starving to death because the central planners did not have infinite knowledge, which the central planning idea requires.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_economy#Disadvantages_... This section of the same wikipedia article shows that markets are more efficient at allocating resources.
#############
It doesn't matter where you go, everywhere you will see markets are better at allocating resources. Politicians implement bad policy because voters demand action. Trump can use the Defense Production Act to command masks be confiscated and sent to a hospital, and he will act like he's a savior, and economically ignorant people will believe it because action looks better than inaction. But he's not doing that because all the economists have said that's the best way to get masks where they need to be. In the end, he's killing people with these kinds of actions, not saving them.
I wouldn't put too much stock in that survey. It was about a specific Connecticut law, it only included 40 economists, many chose not to answer, and many of the others took issue with some vagueness in the wording. Furthermore, I wouldn't blindly follow "economists" on any policy matter. Sure, their ideas have some merit, but their discipline has its biases, too.
> The advantages show the Soviet Union industrializing... while starving to death because the central planners did not have infinite knowledge, which the central planning idea requires.
Oh, please. Anti-price gauging legislation is not central planning. It's pretty weak to trot out the Soviet Union to refute anything but the purest capitalism.
> It doesn't matter where you go, everywhere you will see markets are better at allocating resources.
The first army to learn to allocate supplies to the front lines on free market principles will be unstoppable! /s
https://www.marketplace.org/2017/09/01/why-economists-dont-t... "Economists don't think price gouging is a problem"
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfman/2016/09/23/price... "Price gouging laws are good politics but bad economics"
https://hbr.org/2013/07/the-problem-with-price-gouging-laws "The problem with price gouging laws"
https://www.thoughtco.com/the-economics-of-price-gouging-114... supports price gouging
Can you provide ANY literature suggesting mainstream economists, on average, support price fixing, confiscation, or purchase limits as a means to allocate resources effectively in a crisis?
>The first army to learn to allocate supplies to the front lines on free market principles will be unstoppable! /s
The military primarily gets work done by allowing private contractors to bid on projects. In order to get troops near the front lines, most military personnel take commercial airline flights to get there because it's more efficient. Military operations are wildly inefficient, but they still use markets wherever possible because it gets things done as efficiently as possible.
If you think that, you must not have even read the links you gave me. The first one takes a turn halfway through with "but, as with so much of economics, there is disagreement," and has an economist outline a lot of the problems with price gouging that the other economists are missing.
> Can you provide ANY literature suggesting mainstream economists, on average, support price fixing, confiscation, or purchase limits as a means to allocate resources effectively in a crisis?
Frankly, I don't really care if "mainstream economists, on average" support anti-price gouging legislation or not. Like I alluded to before, they have their biases. For instance, they spend their careers focused on certain problems and not others. That doesn't mean those other problems are unimportant and can be ignored. Good policy will ignore economists in some cases, when factors economists de-prioritize need to be prioritized.
Your qualification of "mainstream" is also kinda interesting. I don't consider economics to be any kind of settled science. It's almost certain that there are serious problems caused by following "mainstream economics" due to its flaws, omissions, and biases. Its ideas should be given due weight, but they're not the gospel truth. That's especially clear on the question of price gouging, because even in the survey you cited there were economists that strongly supported efforts to curb it.
>>> It doesn't matter where you go, everywhere you will see markets are better at allocating resources.
>> The first army to learn to allocate supplies to the front lines on free market principles will be unstoppable! /s
> The military primarily gets work done by allowing private contractors to bid on projects.
That's clearly not what I was talking about. If, as you say, "markets are better at allocating resources" everywhere, don't you think a front line army unit should get supplies allocated to it based on market principles (e.g. the unit bids against other units in a market to get more ammunition)?
No, that's only true if you believe the simplistic myth that a price-driven market is always the best and fairest way to allocate scarce resources, in all circumstances. That myth is false, but it's a seductive myth because the market works very well in many situations.
Price gougers operate only in crises, inserting themselves as middlemen to extract a profit on emergency essentials. They can't do anything to increase supply, because there's no time for that. They don't direct resources to where they're most needed, rather they direct them wherever the most profit is. They perform no social good, and are actually a form of market failure.
> It might also spike demand earlier than it would have spiked, which sends a signal to ramp up production.
That's a fairy tale. The manufacturers aren't solely reliant on price to learn about demand, and they have clearer and more direct ways to communicate with their customers in situations like this. Do you think Purell and 3M needed guys like this [1] to tell them demand for their products was spiking due to an incipient pandemic? No. 3M was literally ramping up in late January [2], before the COVID-19 was even a blip on the price-gouger's radar.
> 1 person snapping up 10,000 masks with intent to sell is better than 100 people snapping up 100 masks each that they intend to stick in their closet "just in case", while people that really need them find empty shelves.
Firstly, there are better ways to manage the surge demand, which the actual businesses involved are implementing: prioritizing sales to customers based on need and implementing retail purchase quotas to prevent people (usually gougers) from buying everything up and creating artificial scarcity.
Secondly, it's likely that the 100 people in your example who bought from the gouger just put the masks in their closest anyway. Gougers take supply out of the normal channels and inflate prices so much that the people who bought from them are worried people with more money than sense, rather than those with real need like nurses and hospitals.
Thirdly, at the maximally inflated prices gougers often sell for, they may end up functionally becoming hoarders themselves and still make a profit. If a gouger buys 1000 masks at $1/per, sells 100 at $10/per, 200 at $5/per, 300 at $2.50/per, and unloads the rest at the original $1/per after it's all over, he's more than doubled his money while wasting half his inventory. He's not looking to speed resources to where they're needed, but milk every cent out of them that he can. The supplies do no more good in a profiteer's garage than in a prepper's closet.
[1] He Has 17,700 Bottles of Hand Sanitizer and Nowhere to Sell Them (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-pu...)
[2] How 3M Plans to Make More Than a Billion Masks By End of Year (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-03-25/3m-double...): "Andrew Rehder, manager of 3M Co.’s respirator mask factory in Aberdeen, S.D., got the call from headquarters on Tuesday, Jan. 21....Rehder told them that a new virus was spreading rapidly in China and that 3M was expecting demand for protective gear to jump....Now, Rehder told his charges, Aberdeen would shift to “surge capacity.” Idle machinery installed for precisely this purpose would be activated, and many of the plant’s 650 employees would immediately start working overtime."
Given how many people are currently unemployed - how is it that we can fail to ramp up our own ability to produce this needed equipment? There is no shortage of labor. Forget about the failures to prepare in January, February and March - what are we doing right now to prepare for the next 6 months?
I'm looking around for a leader who has that vision. Governors are blaming the federal government. The federal government is blaming China and the WHO. Who is organizing the effort to fill the gaps?